My wife's headaches, ( a real sad story, and a great frustrating mystery)

We have a 1993 Caprice Classic which was formally a New Hampshire state

police car. We bought it at state auction in 1998 and my wife drove it with no problems up until about 2 years ago. All of a sudden her headaches seemed to come on gradually and they seemed to occur every time she drove the car. We suspected that it could be Co., and inasmuch

as the muffler was leaking a slight amount anyway we went ahead and replaced the entire exhaust system. I personally checked it carefully for leaks afterwards and ascertained that there were none. She drove the car afterwards and almost instantly got a headache. A mechanic friend suggested that perhaps it could be dampness causing mold. He gave me a 120V ionizer which I was to place in the car, and plug in overnight with the windows closed. He cautioned me though not to use it

if the carpets were wet. I first checked the carpets and did indeed find them wet especially on the front drivers side. We pulled the carpet and to my disappointment we found that a major portion of the floor under the pedal area, going into the corner post and running up the firewall was rusted through badly. New Hampshire uses an unbelievable amount of road salt in the Winter and cars are destroyed by this. We did not use the ionizer. It was a great deal of work but the carpet and padding were both removed and the area was treated with Por15, sheet metal was replaced, the floor was sealed, new carpet was installed and the underside was treated as well. I then borrowed the ionizer again and used it for a full 24 hours. Upon opening the door afterwards the car really smelled "fresh" and I was hopeful that we had

resolved the problem. But still the headaches came. We did have a slight residual smell from the Por15 and there was of course that unmistakeable new carpet smell that only fades with time, so I thought maybe I had created a new problem. So for the whole winter the car just

sat. This spring I got it out, and upon opening it up noted that there was no residual smell left. The carpets were dry and I had my wife drive it two miles and back and she again got a headache. They seem to start at the top of her head and just go on from there. I mentioned this to my mechanic friend again and he suggested that it could still be mold perhaps in the heaing and cooling ducts. I know that moisture does collect in there and rots the blower resistors out. (we replaced the resistor in ours already). So he suggested that I take full strenght bleach in a spray bottle and while the engine is running with the blower on spray the bleach into the cowl vents. I sprayed about a quart while working the controls between heat and AC. I also sprayed the bleach into the vents from the inside of the car as well and also onto the padding that is still up on the firewall. This is a foam material and was not replaced but it is very dry. I kept the windows closed while doing this and the inside of the car smelled really strong, like swimming pool shock after a few minutes and even the next day it still did. I would have hoped that would have killed any mold that might have still been in there. I have driven the car since and have run it in vent position as well as heat and AC and all the chlorine smell is now gone. This afternoon my wife and I went out to the car and just sat in it for 10 minutes with the doors open. The engine was off. We were listening to the radio and she was reading the paper. I was hopeful until after about 15 minutes she mentioned that another headache was coming on again. With the front doors open and the

engine off! I have had many people ride in this car and she is the only

one who can not be near it. This car looks and runs great. I really want to keep it. Of course I'd like my wife to be around too. The car has given us great service but I am at my wits end with this problem. Does ANYONE have any ideas? I appoligize for the long winded story but I wanted to try to provide all the facts. Thanks for any suggestions. Lenny Stein.

Reply to
captainvideo462002
Loading thread data ...

Lenny,

Perhaps your wife should see an allergist. Or just have your doctor test for allergies. I'm not really sure what they do. But this is my best guess at the moment.

Does your wife always drive with the radio on? If there's something screwy with the audio (especially after being in service for who knows how long) it could be producing high frequency audio that some people are sensitive to.

Does she wear glasses? If she wears glasses except when she drives, or only when she drives or reads, this could be a problem as well. Hope some of this helps. :)

Kevin

--
Kevinm
Reply to
Kevinm

" snipped-for-privacy@yahoo.com" bravely wrote to "All" (20 Apr 05 21:53:15) --- on the heady topic of "My wife's headaches, ( a real sad story, and a great frustrating myster"

Did your wife drive another car and have a headache? It may be she has a problem with her neck and turning the head or moving the eyes around a lot causes her headache. It may be that it takes some time to get used to driving again after a long absence from the road.

Perhaps she needs some kind of eye glasses to drive? Driving requires the eyes to focus further away and may cause eye strain which results in the perceived headaches. Since the problem occured with the doors open then it may now be partly in the mind as a memory from the first experience. The brain is really great at trying to avoid dangers which it previously encountered.

As for the carbon monoxide problem try to borrow a detector and check the interior. Look for any openings in the firewall left after the police equipment was removed as any engine fumes might creep in through there. For instance oil that leaks onto a hot manifold but doesn't leak at idle or in park, or leaks from the blow-by valve.

BTW contrary to popular belief bleach doesn't kill mold very well. Ammonia does a better job. Some folk spray Lysol into the A/C vents and swear by it but I'm not convinced. Perhaps a combination of each.

A*s*i*m*o*v

ca> From: " snipped-for-privacy@yahoo.com" ca> Xref: aeinews sci.electronics.repair:46153

ca> We have a 1993 Caprice Classic which was formally a New Hampshire ca> state ca> police car. We bought it at state auction in 1998 and my wife drove it ca> with no problems up until about 2 years ago. All of a sudden her ca> headaches seemed to come on gradually and they seemed to occur every ca> time she drove the car. [,,,]

... No electrons were harmed in the posting of this message.

Reply to
Asimov

Does it only occur in this particular car? What if she drives another? Does it occur if she sits in an identical vehicle?

I'm thinking possibly it's something to do with the driving position, maybe a nerve is getting pinched in her neck or something?

Perhaps it's some form of subconcious anxiety leading to tension headaches? Has she (Or someone she knows) been in a road crash?

Could a fuel leak be causing fumes in the car? Maybe the car has a pressurised fire extinguisher system that is leaking?

sponix

Reply to
s--p--o--n--i--x

Lenny: I think your wife is "trying to tell you" that she wants a NEW car.

-- Best Regards, Daniel Sofie Electronics Supply & Repair

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

ANYONE have any ideas? I appoligize for the long winded story but

Reply to
sofie

Does the car give anyone else headaches? If not, perhaps you should sell it to someone not bothered by whatever's causing them and get a different car that won't give your wife headaches.

Reply to
James Sweet

Does it only happen with the engine running? Unlikely I know, but if so, it might be something to do with subsonic vibrations, maybe an exhause tuning thing, or a panel vibrating. It happens in rally cars sometimes.

Ron(UK)

Reply to
Ron(UK)

Time to make a decision. Sell the car or the wife. I suspect the car's trade-in value may be higher - but you haven't given much detail on the wife for a fair valuation.

But it definitely sounds like the two are mutually incompatible.

A difficult decision, I know. But life's not fair.

Cheers, Alan, Australia

Reply to
Alan S

I didn't catch the beginning of this thread but headaches could be a symptom of carbon monoxide leaking into the passenger compartment. This should be checked out immediately.

--- sam | Sci.Electronics.Repair FAQ Mirror:

formatting link
Repair | Main Table of Contents:
formatting link

+Lasers | Sam's Laser FAQ:
formatting link
| Mirror Sites:
formatting link

Note: These links are hopefully temporary until we can sort out the excessive traffic on Repairfaq.org.

Important: Anything sent to the email address in the message header above is ignored unless my full name is included in the subject line. Or, you can contact me via the Feedback Form in the FAQs.

Reply to
Sam Goldwasser

Lenny, I have worked with people who have environmental illness and migraines. They can develop an acute sensitivity to smells, sounds and all kinds of stimulus even electromagnetic radiation. Things that someone else could never detect or even notice. That said it does not diminish their suffering or the reality of the causation. Does your wife have headaches in any other situation, mental stimulus or location? Richard

Reply to
spudnuty

Sometimes when I use the anhydrous isopropyl in the shop she complains, or smells like paint thinner will bring one on too but they would affect most people I'm sure. She is pre menopausal and perhaps that may have something to do with this. I don't know. Whats so frustrating is that as a technician I repair things for a living and this is something that I just can't seem to fix. Lenny

Reply to
captainvideo462002

Pretty hard to fix something when the symptoms are not apparent to you though.

Reply to
James Sweet

On Thu, 21 Apr 2005 10:29:27 -0700, sofie wrote (in article ):

Take her for a test drive in a new Mercedes. Does she get a headache?

:-)

Seriously, it really sounds like you have covered all the bases. You haven't answered the question about if she gets headaches driving any other cars.

Good luck,

--
Please, no "Go Google this" replies. I wouldn't 
ask a question here if I hadn't done that already. 

DaveC
me@privacy.net
This is an invalid return address
Please reply in the news group
Reply to
DaveC

I would be VERY careful about using a combination of bleach and ammonia. The combination of fumes are toxic!

Reply to
merfturtle

One other possibility may be how the vehicle positions her neck. Some people are more sensitive to how their neck is positioned. Play with the headrest or maybe try a neck support. My 2 cents.

Reply to
borgunit

Check the trunk/rear seat/floorboard area for exhaust gas entry path.

--
E
Reply to
Mr.E

--
Joe Leikhim K4SAT
"The RFI-EMI-GUY"

The Lost Deep Thoughts                        By: Jack Handey
     Before a mad scientist goes mad, there's probably a time
when he's only partially mad.  And this is the time when he's
going to throw his best parties.
Reply to
**THE-RFI-EMI-GUY**

Well I've had good results using Shiatsu treatments and a form of meditation for clients with headaches including migranes. There are many books on the subject. On the technical side you might be interested in:

formatting link
formatting link
Heard about this pulsed magnetic therapy a while back but haven't seen anyone market a commercial product. "Honey would you mind putting this thing on your head while I hook it up to my freq oscillator?" Richard

Reply to
spudnuty

I don't know your wife, and I don't mean this to be a put-down. But the power of suggestion is very strong for some people. In other words, at this point, she may get a headache when she gets into this car simply because she EXPECTS to get a headache when she gets into this car. This cause is especially indicated if the headache comes on nearly instantly, as you have described - so soon that none of the causes being discussed here (exhaust fumes, neck position, lighting, EMI, etc) have had a chance to kick in yet.

I knew a girl like this once, but her particular hot button was food that had sat out on the counter for more than two hours. She was convinced that any kind of food would spoil in that time, and that she would get sick if she ate it. And since she expected to get sick, she did. And she was truly miserable - she wasn't making it up. She would retch and gag and vomit almost instantly if she thought there was even a possibility that the food was "old", even if a dozen other people were happily munching on the same thing.

The headaches may originally have had a legitimate cause, and it could have been any of the things being discussed. But if the power of suggestion is revved up real good, nothing you do is going to make this car tolerable to her. At some point, you may have to just cut your losses.

Bill

------------------------

spudnuty wrote:

Reply to
Bill Jeffrey

Didn't see any mention of this so I thought I'd throw it out for your consideration:

You may want to try having your wife wear a good dust mask over her mouth and nose to filter the air she is breathing. If the headaches disappear or diminish significantly, then at least you will have good idea that the problem is air-borne (like mold) and you will have a better idea of what may be going on. Also, as weird as it may look, at least if you and your wife need to go somewhere in that car, you will have a way to do it (if it works).

In the absence of air-borne problems, your wife may be very sensitive to and be reacting to a very high frequency or very low frequency sound coming from somewhere that is causing her headaches (my wife is an audiologist and suggested that idea). Women, especially, are sensitive to and can hear very high frequencies that men cannot hear, especially as men age. Sounds like that may be originating from some metal part wearing out (break shoes, bearings, etc.) or even a window that isn't closing all the way, causing some road noise.

Best of luck.

Gary

--
glieberman
Reply to
glieberman

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.