1. Home
  2. Field-Programmable Gate Arrays
  3. Verilog-2001 `define expressions?

Verilog-2001 `define expressions?

I was trying to use a macro 'expression' --

`define MAXIMUM2( x, y ) ( ((x)>(y))?(x):(y) ) // return greater value

parameter A_W = 10; // Abus width (#bits) parameter B_W = 12; // Bbus width (#bits) parameter C_W = `MAXIMUM2( A_W, B_W ); // Cbus: intersect(A_W, B_W)

This works in NC-Verilog 4.0, Modelsim 5.6, Design Compiler 2003.06, and Ambit/PKS 5.0. Xilinx ISE 6.1i's "XST" doesn't like it. Overall, so far so good!

Then I tried to get more clever ...

`define MAXIMUM3(x,y,z ) ( (`MAXIMUM2(x,y)>z) ? (`MAXIMUM2(x,y)):(z) )

This barfs on most of the above...

Do any Verilog tools support nested MACROs?

('common, C-programmers have been doing this sort of #define stuff for ages!)

Also don't worry...I'm not using the MACROs to evaluate combinational exprsesions. I use the MACROs in parameter definitions. (I have some data-bus width conversions in a few datapath modules. Each 'node' needs to be sized to the larger of the 2 endpoints.)

Reply to
toby
Loading thread data ...

Note that this could be written more compactly as

`define MAXIMUM3(x,y,z) `MAXIMUM2(`MAXIMUM2(x,y),z)

but this may be even less likely to work, since it involves a macro appearing in a macro argument, not just the expansion text.

I will check the most recent NC-Verilog and file a bug report if necessary.

Incidentally, macros with arguments were added in Verilog-1995, not Verilog-2001. However, a lot of tools probably didn't support them until they started implementing the Verilog-2001 extensions. The standard does not specify whether macros can be nested (i.e. whether the text expansion of a macro is subject to further substitution), but it seems like a reasonable thing to expect.

Reply to
Steven Sharp

I just tested that `define statement in DC_shell 2003.06-SP1 -- it compiles just fine. I also tried

`define MAXIMUM3(x,y,z) `MAXIMUM2(`MAXIMUM2(x,y),z))

again...DC_shell 2003.06-SP1 compiles that just fine.

Reply to
Hona

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.