I recorded some data CDs 3 years ago, using Philips Multi Purpose CDR-74 (650 MB). At the same time, I also made some other data CDs, using Verbatim CDs. I used the same CD recorder (Sony CRX 1611, love it), which I'm still using (still love it).
I have tested 3 of the Philips CDs recently, and all 3 had errors. I did the test making a Nero CD-copy; Nero informs you of any unreadable sector after cancelling the operation. On one CD I ran the test twice and the bad sector that cancelled the operation was different than the first one. This to me indicates not a scratched CD but rather a poor CD-ROM reader.
It's somewhat againt the odd for all 3 CDs going bad, and temperature and humidity have been normal these 3 years, no sunlight, hardly any handling, I'm very careful regardless, and they're not written on.
And the 2 Verbatim CDs from the same time ran the test perfectly, and they were stored together with the Philips, which to me suggests problems reading a certain type of CD; again, a CD-ROM problem, not a problem with the CDs.
Could the reading laser on my CD-ROM (Sony CRX 1611) have dimmed, and it can't read the lower quality stuff anymore? And if so, am I generating lower quality CDs by continuing to use my trusty old Sony to record CDs?