Thats a general well known consideration. Read S.A.Maas Microwave Mixers. To make a direct circuit comparison is ALWAYS dangerous because they are too many variables to consider.
Depends exactly on what you want. If you need l proof on why MOS/ FET Mixers are better then their bipolar counter parts Clark Hess 1971 "Communication Circuits" is the place to go.
Well at 10 Mhz they should be OK. They work well at both vhf and uhf I assume.
One of the 3 possible modes in which you can operate a FET as a mixer is in resistive mode changing the values of the resistance or more specifically the conditions of the MOSFET channel between the source and drain from complete depletion to complete invertion or infinite resistance to zero resistance . In these conditions the FET channel resistance is linear and very low intermodulation distortion results.
The book on Clark Hess above gives a detailed analysis using Bessel functions on why FETs have superior distortion performance compared to their bipolar counterparts.
The Gilbert cell multiplier has a differential output current given by the products of the emitter current, tanh(V1/2Vt) and tanh(V2/2Vt). V1 and V2 being the The only way you can get an analog multiplication of the 2 input signals is by assuming V1 and V2 are SMALL. That is by carrying out the Taylor expansion of the tanh expression and approximating it as V1/2Vt. Thats why predistortion is used in Gilbert cells.
Mos have much higher p-p input signal ... compare the mathematical expression for the output drain current in a dual gate Mosfet . id = ....+...+ kVg1*Vg2+.... . k is a numerical constant. The drain current has no limitations as is the case for the Gilbert cell.
Try looking at the following . Tsironis Meierer and R. Stahlmann Dual Gate Mesfet mixers "IEEE Transactions on Microwave theory and Techniques" Vol MTT-32,No.3 Mar.1984"
S.Weaver "TV Design considerations Using Dual Gate MOSFETS "IEEE Transactions on broadcast and Television receivers, Vol. BTR 19 , May
1973"You don't seem to get the point of my original post . The Op wanted some advice on both discrete and integrated circuit implementation of a mixer. Well while everyone was saying Gilbert cell I wanted him to know there were other options ... None of which were mentioned by anybody! I admitted in my first post they weren't necessarily the best and it would be challenging to use them... but if I was him I'd have taken that road.
"Go easy on the whisky"
theJackal