Re: Evil Designers Guide to Copying Patents

Mar 21, 2007 5 Replies


12) Get ready to mass produce the patent just before the patent expires.


You probably aren't old enough to remember the Polaroid Swinger case.


The Polaroid Land camera was the first camera that gave you a print in 60 seconds. Big companies were all tooled up to jump on the tech the day the patent expired, so they could get a piece of the 60-second photo action.


The day before the patent expired, Polaroid released the "Swinger", (named for its wrist strap), which used a whole new film technology that they'd spent the previous 16 years and 364 days developing, and avoided a whole bunch of hassles that the previous one had. Nobody bought the old-tech units from any of the competitors, because the old Land camera technology became obsolete virtually overnight.


Cheers! Rich

Well, I see that as a rare case where the patent system worked right. Polaroid spent part of their profits as research dollars making real improvements, while the rest sat on their asses waiting for their copies to become legal.

If the patent system were used as it should be, DfBC's list would be a sure recipe for corporate failure.

John Perry

An example that an expired patent maybe just that...expired ..totally. Just a stepping stone to new tech. Interesting story :) D from BC

I remember Kodak coming out with their own version and losing the lawsuit big-time. I still see the cameras in thrifts here and there - no film for them so what's the point?

Looks more like NOT patenting their new stuff worked - and keeping their mouth shut for 16 years.

Gerhard

That wouldn't have worked if the patent system hadn't worked (before or after).

Keith

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required