Mis-matching & matching (was Dumb question...)

Hi Guys,

From what I have been able to absorb now from all of your really terrific responses is that it is totally and completely impossible to LC match, even theoretically, a purposefully mis-matched active device*, and then look back into that mis-matched network and see a perfect 50 ohms. However, the purposefully mis-matched active device WILL get to see the impedance it wants to see. And all this is due to the reciprocal nature of LC matching networks. Thus, it would be wise, as you have all mentioned, to design any non-50 ohm LNA or PA to be as close to 50 ohms as possible, or to design the next connecting stage so that it properly works with something other than 50 ohms -- 'cause there is no way to "fix" this mis-match issue with a LC matching network. Is that correct, or have I misunderstood something? (I can't believe I didn't know -- or didn't understand -- this stuff from the get-go! A major glitch in my knowledge-base, that's for sure.)

Many Thanks,

-Bill

*The mis-match created so as to optimize an LNA transistor's input for NF, or a PA transistor's output for P1dB, to name two common reasons.

(HAD TO OPEN-UP A NEW THREAD BECAUSE GOOGLE GROUPS APPARENTLY REFUSED TO POST THIS, EVEN AFTER TWO TRIES -- OR AT LEAST IT DID NOT SHOW UP)

Reply to
billcalley
Loading thread data ...

Bill, your original post did show up, twice. I don't use Google Groups but sometimes I search groups via Google. The results are a bit mixed lately, used to be 100% accurate but no more after they "fancified" their GUI.

--
Regards, Joerg

http://www.analogconsultants.com
Reply to
Joerg

yes I think that is correct for reciprocal matching networks i.e standard L C or transformer..

you can do it with pads but it makes no sense to use pads in this application..

I did think of another way, CIRCULATORS are non-reciprocal devices, so in theory you CAN do it using a circulator... but a circulator is probably not practical for your application. The theory is interesting, you may want to read up on them... but for your application you probably just need to compromise the match between noise figure and filter flatness.

Mark

Reply to
Mark

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.