Absurdly Dangerous Militarization of America's Police
Jan 13, 2014 42 Replies
G
Greegor
formatting link
The Absurdly Dangerous Militarization of America's Police By Jim Hightower, Other Words 09 January 2014 Police departments across the U.S. have a growing collection of toys used by the army. What a Christmas little Bastrop had! It's still a mystery how Santa Claus got it down the chimney, but Bastrop got a nifty present that most children could only dream about: A big honkin', steel-clad, war toy called MRAP. But Bastrop is not a six-year-old child, and an MRAP is not a toy. Bastrop is a Texas county of some 75,000 people, and MRAP stands for "Mine-Resistant Ambush Protected." It's a heavily-armored military vehicle weighing about
15 tons - one of several versions of fighting machines that have become the hot, must-have playthings of police departments all across the country. Are the good people of Bastrop facing some imminent terrorist threat that warrants military equipment? No, it's a very pleasant, laid-back place. And while the county is named for a 19th century land developer and accused embezzler, it's never been a haven for particularly dangerous criminals - indeed, the relatively few crimes in Bastrop today don't rise above the level of routine police work. Even the sheriff's department, which is the proud owner of the MRAP tank, says it doesn't have a specific use for the machine, but "It's here if we need it." Well, yeah ... but that same feeble rational would apply if the county decided to get an atom bomb - you just never know when a big mushroom cloud might come in handy! What we have here is the absurdly dangerous militarization of America's police departments. Our sprawling Department of Homeland Security and the Pentagon (which gave the MRAP to Bastrop) are haphazardly spreading war equipment, war techniques and a war mentality to what are supposed to be our communities' peacekeepers and crime solvers. Having the technology and mindset for military actions, local authorities will find excuses to substitute them for honest police work, turning common citizens into "enemies." As a spokesman for the Bastrop sheriff's department said of the MRAP, "With today's society ... there's no way the thing won't be used." How comforting is that? But now, let's turn from the battlefield to the gridiron. In the ever-escalating competition to be the No. 1 big-time college football program in the nation, Ohio State University bulked up last fall with a monster recruit named Maxx. Actually, it's not the coaching staff that signed up this brute, but the OSU campus police department. And the recruit's full name is MaxxPro - not a player, but a 19-ton armored fighting vehicle built by a pentagon contractor to withstand "ballistic arms fire, mine fields, IEDs, and Nuclear, Biological and Chemical environments." Wow, college games really have gotten rough! But the campus PD, which received the MaxxPro as a gift from the Pentagon (ie, us taxpayers), says it's not just playing games, but deploying Maxx for things like hostage scenarios, killers loose on campus, and extreme flooding of up to three feet. Well, have such things been a problem at OSU? Uh ... no. Would a huge, slow, gas-guzzling vehicle designed for warfare be effective if any of the above were actually to occur? No response. Oh, by the way, operating these machines requires specially trained personnel - is anyone in the department qualified? Again, no answer. Also, the vehicles are subject to frequent rollovers, and they lack the ability to go off-road or to maneuver in confined areas. That doesn't sound ideal for a college campus. Not to worry, though, for the gendarmes said they were adjusting Maxx to fit their needs. How? Removing the top gun turret and repainting the vehicle. OSU police finally admitted that Maxx would mostly be used to drive them around campus and provide a police "presence" on football game days. Great - police authorities now believe they need a show of military force to keep tailgaters in check.
+26 # EmilyCragg 2014-01-09 13:58 There's a prevalent Game Theory that the Government needs to be protected from the People ... a theme prevalent in our Constitution. And the reason for THAT PARANOIA lies in policies and practices surrounded in Secrecy, Confidentiality , Non-Disclosure, Compartmentalization, Need-to-Know and Classified documents. When the Government is no longer accountable, bad things happen ... and they have to start legislating protections for men doing harm unlawfully. EEWC
+20 # CuttySark 2014-01-09 22:37 Those who watched a recent Bill Maher show heard Bill interviewing a guy who opposes feeding "the hand that turns us into steel-and-iron monsters." So beyond feeding the hand that arms us unnecessarily, we're paying to give the government more money to spend down at Artillery makers' Mall. Doesn't it bring tears to your eyes? What should the money really be spent on? Anybody?
+24 # USA2012??? 2014-01-10 02:26 Only a complete idiot would take the actions of arming police departments with such lethal equipment lightly without assuming something far more serious is about to happen. There will be no invasion of foreign governments on US shores, therefore unless there's an alien invasion from outer space about to happen, what on earth could all of this internal big gun diplomacy possibly be for? Public beware: absolute power corrupts absolutely!
+13 # RLF 2014-01-10 05:15 And armed also with the NDAA so that they can bring in the national guard and kill american citizens will-nilly.
+28 # maverita 2014-01-10 05:27 i am a sweet little (5' tall) 60 year old lady who had not had even a traffic ticket in over 20 years. i was stopped by bastrop deputies and they were just horrible. i had been out of state for months my inspection sticker was out of date. they made me exit my vehicle and when i tried to get a leash on my dog they almost taised me. after searching my vehicle and all that drama, when my story was verified i was finally let go with a warning. for decades our police departments have made it a point to hire people who are of average intelligence who are not critical thinkers and who will follow orders. long gone are the neighborhood cops that knew your kids names. this new breed are scary.
+15 # Glen 2014-01-10 08:52 I have friends just south of that area, so have visited and toured Bastrop areas. There is no reason, in such an area, for one such as yourself to have been put through all that for nothing. That attitude on the part of cops will be one more reason citizens will eventually begin to fight back in earnest. So much has been lost over the years in the U.S., and it is highly notable in rural areas, where peace and quiet at one time reigned - not to mention decent human interaction.
+26 # tedrey 2014-01-10 07:30 These are not intended for terrorists or any other valid police function. They have two purposes only; to make money for arms manufacturers and to put down citizen protests. Every community should insist that the police have no such weaponry, and should remove all officials who support bringing it in.
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
B
Bill Sloman
And you are posting to sci.electronics.design because you find it interesting, even though it has nothing to do with electronics?
I'd take it kindly if you didn't do it again.
Bill Sloman, Sydney
R
Robert Baer
An ostrich eventually gets kicked in the ass,or worse. In this case,Herr Obama will be doing a LOT of kicking with help from his cop "friends". He has already illegally trashed thousands of corporate contracts (remember GM?) and trashed various parts of the Constitution (TSA, Homeland Security, etc).
J
John Fields
Since you seem to have no qualms about your posting off-topic
twaddle, one finds it amusing that you request others not to follow
suit.
Perhaps you find being roused from your turpor by his "irrelevant
rubbish" disturbing?
J
Jim Thompson
Well? They _are_ coming to get Slowman, aren't they ?:-) ...Jim Thompson
| James E.Thompson | mens |
| Analog Innovations | et |
| Analog/Mixed-Signal ASIC's and Discrete Systems | manus |
| San Tan Valley, AZ 85142 Skype: Contacts Only | |
| Voice:(480)460-2350 Fax: Available upon request | Brass Rat |
| E-mail Icon at http://www.analog-innovations.com | 1962 |
I love to cook with wine. Sometimes I even put it in the food.
A
Adrian Jansen
... snip...
1) You are off-topic for this group
2) And the media would have us believe that its only criminals who have and use dangerous weapons.
Actually, should these things not be classed as WMDs ? Look what happened to Saddam Hussein ?
Regards,
Adrian Jansen adrianjansen at internode dot on dot net
Note reply address is invalid, convert address above to machine form.
B
Bill Sloman
sting, even though it has nothing to do with electronics?
e finds it amusing that you request others not to follow suit.
I don't initiate off-topic threads, though I do participate in off-topic th reads that others initiate. Quite a few threads that start up on-topic have been known to move into to off-topic areas. You've been vocal on perceived personality defects from time to time.
rubbish" disturbing?
The word is "torpor". You seem to have inadvertently created a blend with " turpitude" and "stupor".
Greegor does get up my nose, and to that extent he moves me to react to his posts. I wouldn't describe my non-posting condition as torpor - I'm just d oing other stuff of no particular significance.
Bill Sloman, Sydney
G
Greegor
I was amazed to see this from a self proclaimed "progressive" writer. What kind of diodes do they use in these skull crushing tanks? Did you see where our government was going to destroy or abandon machines like this in Afghanistan that barely got used? They cost us many BILLIONS to build yet they won't even haul them back to US bases. I never saw any rationalization of that. Is it possible that our military doesn't want wheeled tanks like this? Is that because drones will outmode most of the police______military force anyway?
L
Lasse Langwadt Christensen
Den tirsdag den 14. januar 2014 01.10.40 UTC+1 skrev Greegor:
both side of the mud slinging fence like to say they create jobs one side just prefer that those jobs involve things painted in camouflage so they won't be accused of being socialist
and if any of them start to think it is a waste of money there's a horde of lobbyist standing in line to put them in place
-Lasse
D
DecadentLinuxUserNumeroUno
On Mon, 13 Jan 2014 09:22:11 -0700, Jim Thompson Gave us:
Can we fine them for being two decades late?
J
John Fields
Non sequitur, since the initiation of off-topic threads wasn't part
of the argument.
J
jurb6006
Other recipients: wrote: >>On Tuesday, 14 January 2014 03:00:24 UTC+11, ..."
Now how the hell is that supposed to knockout a tank ?
B
Bill Sloman
of the argument.
How so? It was exactly what I was objecting to.
off-topic posting.
Not so much laissez-faire as an enthusiastic initiator when it comes to taking existing threads off-topic.
Your idea of fun involves a pair of inductors with a coupling factor of exactly one and no associated capacitance.
Simulating a circuit which you couldn't possibly build because it depends on an ideal - and non-existent - component isn't a sensible way of occupying your time.
It rather reminds me of your low-current 100kHz oscillator, which also depended on an inductor with no inter-turn capacitance.
Bill Sloman, Sydney
J
John Fields
Only by inference, as explained after the fact.
Had you been less careless and more specific the first time around,
your meaning would likely have been clear.
J
John Fields
On Tue, 14 Jan 2014 20:40:32 -0800 (PST), Bill Sloman initiated this off-topic thread after having written:
"I don't initiate off-topic threads, though I do participate in off-topic threads that others initiate." to:
news: snipped-for-privacy@googlegroups.com
JF
B
Bill Sloman
On Wednesday, 15 January 2014 21:35:46 UTC+11, John Fields wrote:
interesting, even though it has nothing to do with electronics?
le, one finds it amusing that you request others not to follow suit.
pic threads that others initiate.
the argument.
For those with normal reading comprehension, the inference was obvious enou gh not to need to be explicitly spelled out for the sake of the implication
-blind.
meaning would likely have been clear.
I'm sure it was perfectly clear to anybody with normal powers of comprehens ion and inference detection. Posting it in the verbal equivalent of braille would have struck most readers as being fussy and overly pedantic.
to to off-topic areas. You've been vocal on perceived personality defects f rom time to time.
posting.
taking existing threads off-topic.
r join threads that have already been ruined by having been taken off topic .
Well that is the way you would remember it, along with the eventual triumph of your relentless logic. More objective observers might see it all differ ently.
I'm sure it does - to you.
c poster, with you being high on the list of offenders.
I do post a lot here - not as much as John Larkin and Jim Thompson so you'd end up being preoccupied with them ...
ubbish" disturbing?
with "turpitude" and "stupor".
to his posts. I wouldn't describe my non-posting condition as torpor - I'm just doing other stuff of no particular significance.
exactly one and no associated capacitance.
ave been obvious to anyone skilled in the art that it's merely an artifact used to illustrate a concept.
If you'd been to my web-site you'd have found a few slightly more interesti ng concepts that looked vaguely like that.
They were still there last time I looked, but they aren't accessible at the moment. My new information provider seems prone to updating their server p rograms ...
Here's one of them. It needs a break-before make waveform, which I got by d umping the digital divider and setting up the pulse sequences directly, whi ch didn't help things all that much.
It's not that so much, as wondering what you thought you were doing.
s on an ideal - and non-existent - component isn't a sensible way of occupy ing your time.
circuit would function using real parts, so your critique is unfounded.
The simulation would have been more informative if you'd simulated a slight ly more realistic transformer, and your array of D-type flip-flops didn't s eem to be doing anything useful
epended on an inductor with no inter-turn capacitance.
Thread "micro power square wave oscillator", your post on the 4th July 2008 .
I got it to work with a somewhat lower inductance - more or less real - ind uctor. Broad-band transistors offered a cheaper and less bulky solution.
Bill Sloman, Sydney
J
John Fields
But, since you fault everyone as being sub-normal with respect to
reading comprehension, one would expect your presentation to be a
little more concise.
B
Bill Sloman
reading comprehension, one would expect your presentation to be a little more concise.
I've complained that you and Jamie are weak on reading comprehension. Most of the other posters here don't have any trouble seeing implications - James Arthur can see them where they don't exist.
It would seem to be necessary.
circuit would function using real parts, so your critique is unfounded.
feel free to make it as realistic as you like.
Without some idea of what it might be intended to do, realism seems a long way off.
non-overlapping (break-before-make) gate drives for the MOSFETS.
You could have done by specifying the pulse sequence more carefully. In real life you'd do all of that in one programmable logic device and level-shift the relevant outputs to drive the MOSFETs
Not at the current consumption asked for.
Neither of which would meet the current consumption figure, which was unreasonably low. Charging and discharging the drain-to-emitter capacitances of regular devices at 100kHz used up all the current budget and then some.
Maybe regular devices have gotten smaller since then, but I doubt it.
Your LC oscillator buried that capacitance in the LC tank, which helped. I went for BFR92 broad-band transistors because they have a very low collector-emitter capacitance.
Bill Sloman, Sydney
B
Bill Sloman
ting concepts that looked vaguely like that.
he moment. My new information provider seems prone to updating their server programs ...
ally got by dumping the digital divider and setting up the pulse sequences directly, which didn't help things all that much.
I've edited a few files and seem to have got the web-site more or less work ing again. The relevant URL is
formatting link
r3.htm
It's not all that interesting. The context was trying to reduce the third h armonic content of the - reasonable - sine wave you get out of a Baxandall class-D inverter. It's normally about 40dB below the fundamental if you don 't load the tank circuit too heavily.
This sort of pulse width modulation helps a bit, but not as much as I'd hop ed.
More elaborate modulation - Don Lancaster's "magic sine waves" - could, in theory, do better.
Bill Sloman, Sydney
J
John Fields
Well, let's see now...
I post a fun circuit for the purpose of discussion, and you
immediately pooh-pooh it while stating that you don't understand how
it works.
A little help is given and then you disparage the work that went
into the implementation of the design and then suggest that - even
though a hardware simulation was being presented - higher
abstraction would have been preferable.
No doubt because you initially couldn't fathom the hardware
circuitry then - once you were apprised of its function and learned
the trick - suggested that a timing diagram was superior to the
hardware implementation in order to throw up a smoke screen and make
it seem like you hadn't been flummoxed by your own ignorance.
Next, in an attempt to keep your further ignorance from coming to
light, you try to derail the discussion of the fun circuit by
bringing up all sorts of attractive-seeming irrelevances and
substituting them as topics for discussion; the old
"bait-and-switch" trick.
At this point i'm no longer interested in providing a platform for
your self-aggrandisement, so I'll disengage.
John Fields,
Professional Circuit Designer
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.