7805 replacement thingie

May 15, 2008 11 Replies

There seem to be several swicthmode regulators that are packaged to drop into a TO-220 7805-type regulator place. I have a board that has



+12, and I need +5 and 3.3, maybe 500 mA each, and there's no room to place switcher parts, so I have to go vertical. This seems like an easy way to do it.

I could use two, or maybe I could just use one of these to get to +5, then use a tiny MHz switcher to get to 3.3. It's that first step that takes a lot of room... switcher chips that run from +12 generally are non-synchronous at low frequencies, so need a schottky and a big L.


Has anybody used any of these packaged switchers? Any recommendations, comments?



John



No, nor have I seen any literature or articles about them. Point me to a url for one of them if you would be so kind.

Jim

-- "It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it." --Aristotle

We've used Datel's 7805SR in an application that required a large voltage swing (from peak charge voltage down to dead battery) and it was the answer to the build/buy question for some low production rate equipment. It just works.

Rich Webb Norfolk, VA

Yup. You'll get some tones that you don't have with a linear part. Other than that they are quite good. TI PT5105 for example.

The parts you are thinking of are the Powertrends 3-pin SIP modules, now sold by TI. (What you and I would call "TO-220 compatible" they call "3-pin SIP"!) For example PT78HT205.

I've used them, but only in a "we're not going to lay out this PCB again" sense because of their priciness. They are actually bigger than a TO-220 but that's generally OK because they don't need heatsinking for the same voltage drop at current.

Tim.

Vibration may be an issue. According to my experience they won't survive a ride on a tank without extra support. The leads will break.

Programmeren in Almere? E-mail naar nico@nctdevpuntnl (punt=.)

I'm also pretty sure if the tank drives over the switcher, the leads will break also. Although some testing may be required to be 100% sure.

And if it drives over a land mine, you'll probably have different things to worry about than the condition of your regulator leads! ;-)

Cheers! Rich

Yup. Most of them address mounting as an afterthought, or no thought at all. At least a 7805 has a tab with a hole in it.

John

Transport vibration can be enough. Seen lots of grief there, to the point where we'd remove the bottom fan assy and swipe the bottom with broom and shovel. Let's see, what have we here? Oh, looks like pieces of a toroid. Look, here's a crystal. And an electrolytic over there.

Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ "gmail" domain blocked because of excessive spam. Use another domain or send PM.

These look interesting:

formatting link

Have Fun! Rich

I've used a lot of the +5 Powertrends. Pay close attention to the app notes. They often have have specific load requirements, like a zener or a low ESR ceramic. I think there are other brand available now.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required