Which snubber board of these two is better?

For $9.99, I bought a single lot of 16 snubber boards for the same Toshiba IGBTs as the ones that I own. They came from the same seller as the one who sold me the four IGBTs on heatsink for $50.

There are two kinds of boards in the lot, eight of each kind.

One (marked with 1 on the photos) seems to be a simple RCD design and features WIMA capacitors, Ixys FRED diodes, etc. It seems to be missing the resistor between J11 and J12 (see pictures).

Another (marked 2 on the photo) seems to be some sort of RCD design with an inductor for some reason, and actually with resistors.

I am thinking that I should simply install these snubber boards, one on each of the four IGBTs, and not think too much. To that, I would add an extra big RC snubber just in case.

I am leaning towards #2.

Any thoughts?

i
Reply to
Ignoramus22022
Loading thread data ...

Either you forgot to include a link or you tried to include an attachment.

formatting link

Reply to
JeffM

formatting link

Sorry, they are here

formatting link

i
Reply to
Ignoramus29530

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.