Sales Tax Laws Got Complicated

Aug 27, 2019 28 Replies

Doesn't matter. It's a red herring. Taxes aren't about "fair". They are about bringing money into the government.

BTW, I recently saw a YouTube video about "Malicious Compliance" meaning wh at employees do when the company insists on ignoring your inputs and orderi ng you to do stupid things. Finally the employee gives up and does exactly what they've been ordered and let things go to crap.

I don't remember what story I wanted to relate about that, but the stories are pretty amazing. It had something to do with competing.

A lot of people are afraid of selling over the Internet since you have to u se credit cards and more likely some service like PayPal which allows you t o be ripped off by the unscrupulous.

I have no special admiration of local businesses. They are just people and some people are good, others suck. Whether they stay around seldom has an ything to do with me even if I try to help. Most small businesses are doom ed to failure because the owners have no idea how to run their business... which brings us back to "Malicious Compliance" videos. One included a guy working as a dishwasher in a coffee shop for a new owner who didn't want to be the manager or pay a manager. This guy was constantly overworked but b ecause it was his first job he didn't know it. One day the owner comes in and the place is slammed, the dishwasher is washing stuff by hand just so t he baristas can have something NOW. The owner tells the guy to clear table s and sweep, etc and takes over on the dishwasher. 15 minutes later they o wner is nearly in tears and begs the dishwasher to come back in the kitchen and resume making it work. lol The owner never yelled at him again.

In defense of SCOTUS they are not going to allow states to require *every* seller to collect taxes. There are thresholds (which seem to be set by the states?). I think Maryland is setting a $200,000 per year and some quanti ty of shipments minimum which will drop to $100,000 per year in the near fu ture. I think I read other states are similar. So the "mom and pop" store s can avoid the cost and hassle of knowing all the taxing jurisdictions whi ch are a lot more than just the states. I'm sure I've said before that cou nties and even cities get into the act with sales tax. So there are going to be services that calculate the tax and likely skim the tax from the sale and convey it to the jurisdiction. I think MD requires quarterly sales ta x payments. I could have done it all over the Internet if I had anything t o report, but because I never collected tax on my B2B sales I had to file w ith paper including a form that said I understood that I had the option of filing paperlessly or something equally MASH like. Sign here, initial here , here and here, then sign to say you initialed instead of signing.

ith sales

hased

The state sees it as "sales" that they aren't getting their fair share of t ax from. It's that simple. There is something going on that they weren't allowed to tax and it got bigger every year.

In most states we are taxed on the money when we make it. We are taxed on the money when we spend it. We are taxed for the simple fact that we own s ome things. We are taxed because we use some stuff that isn't ours. I'm n ot certain, but I believe we are taxed (or have to pay fees) simply because we exist and can't live without doing some things we are taxed on.

Give it a try sometime. Shove a bunch of money in your pocket, say $10,000 and leave your home to sleep in a tent someplace where you aren't charged, like along the Appalachian trail. See how much of that money still goes t o paying taxes... I mean if you aren't arrested for having that much cash o n you. Or the cops simply take your money without arresting you. Civil As set Forfeiture: another SCOTUS c*ck up if there ever was one.

Sometimes living in a "free" country doesn't feel so free.

Everything's free in America For a slight fee in America

Rick C. +- Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging +- Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

Nothing to do with competition. No legal argument for this issue was based on "unfair competition".

IT'S ABOUT THE MONEY... the money the states see they are "loosing".

Don't kid yourself.

Rick C. ++ Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging ++ Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

com:

e:

t

ate

in

uction,

e store

nd tear' on

ravel driveway. :^)

suppose

posed

y a

ad spins.

purchases'.

are store we

n
d

quire

ax to

Pop

w York

fairly compete with those who doesn't

ng

They aren't doing business in New York. Perhaps New York should make it il legal for residents to not pay the tax on their own? Oh yeah, states tried that and virtually no one paid it. To get around the federal prohibition on extending your sales tax to other states they even tried calling it a "u se" tax whatever the heck that is. In the end it's just more legal mumbo j umbo to keep people from knowing enough to resist.

Rick C. --- Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging --- Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

That ship has sailed mostly due to SCOTUS saying the feds get the final word in any argument. It was many years that the states though they were sovereign until they found they just weren't as sovereign as the fed.

I would have commented on a few other points, but I couldn't cope with the trimming and fixing the attributions.

Rick C. --+ Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging --+ Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

if they are selling to stuff people who live in New York and ship it to New York they are

That must be why Aliexpress is collecting US tax. They are really big on sticking to their treaties.

Rick C. -+- Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging -+- Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

com:

hoo.com:

edent

e

to

and

s state

sed in

production,

dware store

ar and tear' on

ng gravel driveway. :^)

, I suppose

x imposed

ed by a

y head spins.

x on purchases'.

ardware store we

d can

Y and

n require

es tax to

hing

lect

m-n-Pop

n New York

d unfairly compete with those who doesn't

lowing

Not really. That's like saying a British company is doing business in New York if they ship to New York. There are zero requirements to do that. Yo u don't have to register with New York, you don't have to obey New York reg ulations of any sort. You don't have to deal with New York in any other ma nner other than collecting their sales tax. So how the hell can you call t hat "doing business in New York"???

No, they are doing business where ever their office is, not the location th ey are shipping to.

Rick C. -++ Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging -++ Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

All a bunch of s*it. I don't mean you, I mean this situation. If you ship internationally, you expect Russians to pay for your local schools and pools ?

If you are in California how come I have to contribute to your toxicity ? Like the 13 gender thing, I have to pay you for that because I bought something from Amazon ?

Go f*ck yourself. (not you)

You are seriously weird. What does 13 gender have to do with sales tax??? Only in your mind can these things be warped so they have any similarity at all.

Rick C. +-- Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging +-- Tesla referral code - https://ts.la/richard11209

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required