I bought a PICKit2 and a PICKit3 from MicroChip direct. The day the order came in the PICKit2 worked great but the PICKit3 was very flaky, it would somewhat work when you held pressure on it. Anyway, after a week or so with support.microchip.com they sent me a new PICshit3 board, the new one wouldn't even connect at all, not once. They marked my support "ticket" as closed and I am expected to pay shipping to send their bad board back to them. The PICKit2 works great, not one problem, my original PICKit3 is flaky, works sometimes, the replacement PICKit3 wouldn't even connect properly one time, it is detected and passes the self test, but won't connect. They send out junk and expect the customer to pay to return, buyer beware!
Anyway, thanks to David L Jones's review for letting me know that the PICKit2 was better, at least I got something that works. I have a few interesting designs in the works, I hope I have better luck with Atmel microcontrollers.
RogerN