Charge & Discharge waveforms of lead acid battery Vs Super Capacitor

May 23, 2006 2 Replies

I've an application where I need to know the charging and discharging response time of lead acid battery used in autos. Can you be kind enough to show me how to obtain this data. In particular, I want to compare the charging and discharging response waveform between lead acid battery and super capacitor which has an ESR of about 70 milliohms. Thank you in advance.



Basically, the lead acid battery charges much slower, stores *way* more energy, and then discharges just as slow.

On the other hand, the super capacitor can be discharged all the way down to zero volts; this will kill a lead acid battery.

Luhan

Go to a battery manufacturers website. Most have graphs of the curves for their batteries. There are a _lot_ of variables though. Batteries are a chemical device, and give a very flat output voltage for most of their discharge. However their ability to deliver power at high currents, falls faster than a simple 'resistive' loss, as a result of limitations in the rate of chemical action (also the actual resistance of the cell changes as it discharges). This gives a curve called the 'Peukert curve', which characterises how batteries perform at higher discharge rates. Batteries also have quite complex charge requirements, with many types undergoing accelerated decay if charged wrongly. A capacitor conversely has a relatively simple linear discharge, and can be charged by a simple voltage source, with a current limit to prevent damage. The battery has the big advantage that more of it's discharge cycle is spent at relatively higher voltages, making it simpler to make efficient use of the power.

formatting link
for an 'overview' about batteries, and:
formatting link

Best Wishes

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required