What's the "minimum Ah input during initial charge" of a lead acid battery

Do you have a question? Post it now! No Registration Necessary

Translate This Thread From English to

Threaded View

For a 12V 150AhC10 battery - we charge at 10%, 15A till the voltage/cell  
reaches 2.36V.

So why do we have this 'Minimum Ah input During Initial Charge' setting?
In another spec it says:

"Minimum Ah input 450% of C10 capacity" for a 200Ah C10 battery.
450% is something like 900Ah or 4.5 times the base Ah.. wth?

Re: What's the "minimum Ah input during initial charge" of a lead acid battery
On Fri, 03 Jul 2020 15:07:53 +0000, Veek M wrote:

Quoted text here. Click to load it

Assuming he means some kind of absolute minimum charging current.. how  
would that make sense because the battery starts charging at 10% of C10Ah  
which is huge.. 15A..

Also, if the battery is comprised of numerous cells (12V-nominal/2.36Vpc  
gives the total cells - 5 cells in series.) So 15A is the charge current  
to all the cells.. ergo..  

(and another Q, how does he check the per-cell voltage is 2.36V because  
if they are in series.. does he just assume when he sees 12V across all  
of them?)

Re: What's the "minimum Ah input during initial charge" of a lead acid battery
You need a basic lesson in Lead Acid Battery chemistry:


Amps - the amount of current a battery can put out at a given voltage.
Volt - the energy behind those Amps above.  
Amp-Hour -  How much energy that battery can produce for one hour at a give
n voltage.  
Self-Discharge - the amount of potential energy the battery loses while sit
ting inert.  

Now, a battery is a chemical engine, in this case using lead and lead dioxi
de plates submerged in diluted sulphuric acid, separated into cells. The ch
emical reaction (exactly what that is not important) is limited by the surf
ace area available for the reaction and the strength of the electrolyte (ac

So, a 450AH battery is one that will deliver 450 amps for one hour before c
omplete discharge.  Such a battery will self-discharge at 22.5 AH per month
. For ease-of-math, let's use one (1) AH per day. That is 42 ma per hour. S
o a maintenance charger would have to make at least 42 ma per hour to overc
ome self-discharge.  

Anything more than that will (theoretically) 'charge' the battery, assuming
 a (partially) discharged state initially. A fully charged battery subject  
to additional charging (overcharge) will 'sulphate' - break down the  water
 in the electrolyte into Oxygen and Hydrogen, increasing the acid concentra
tion. Actual voltages are greater than 2.1 V per cell in order to initiate  
and maintain the chemical reaction required to reverse discharge.  

Meaning that charging a battery is a balancing act.  

Going through your questions:  
a) Absolute minimum charging current: That which will overcome self-dischar
b & c) Some industrial batteries have the individual cell anodes and cathod
es accessible for just that purpose. Otherwise, one takes the total divided
 by six (6) for a nominal 12V battery. The resting voltage for a lead-acid  
battery is very roughly 2.1 V per cell.  

Temperature  Charging Voltage/Cell  Charging Voltage (12V)  Gassing Voltage

Temperature: Chemistry, remember. Reactions are affected by temperature.
Charging Voltage per Cell: What it takes to initiate and maintain the chemi
cal reaction for charging. NOT equivalent to resting voltage.  
Gassing Voltage: what will initiate electrolysis in a fully discharged batt
ery, and cause some electrolysis during the charging process. WHAT THIS MEA
NS: why it is that lead-acid batteries need to be checked for electrolyte s
tatus water is lost during the charging process, always, to some degree.  

Lead acid batteries are not complicated, but they are also prone to abuse a
nd failure if the basic chemistry is not understood.  

Peter Wieck
Melrose Park, PA

Re: What's the "minimum Ah input during initial charge" of a lead acid battery
Pretty good post on that Peter.  

There are a few more things though. When the battery is bad it is usually a
 near open circuit. To restore it you need a much higher voltage and you ha
ve to babysit it unless you build a cool circuit for that. When it does not
 pull any charging current how can it charge ? And then sometimes you get a
 shorted cell.  

Another thing is if it a not a gel cell you need to agitate it. Proof ? Cha
rging a battery I kick it around a little and the ammeter on the charger go
es up. That means I knocked the bubbles off the plates.  

And then if you really can't get it to take a charge, (pull current) put ep
som salt in it. That will restore almost any of them BUT, for one you can o
nly do it once. If you do it again you risk a shorted cell and actually the
 thing might blow up. That is rare but it happens.  

Another thing is the desulfater. You take 120 AC, put a light bulb in serie
s like a DBT and hook that up for a while. A 100 watt bulb on 120 only lets
 a little more than one amp through, so it is safe.  

The AC washes the plates, gets the nonconducting coating off them so they c
an work. It has to conduct or you get nothing. They actually sell desulfate
rs but you can do it with a light bulb. Some of the ones they sell use a hi
gher frequency and I don't even know who to ask if that is better.  

Anyway, there is no minimum charging current, it is all in how long it will
 take. Just to do not exceed the maximum. Charge it at 50 amps and the plat
es get all bent out of shape. And the thing could blow up, you know even if
 it can supply 50 amps it is not meant to do it all day. It can't. By the s
ame token you cannot charge it all day at that rate.  

Know what, just go to the boneyard and get an alternator from a 1970 luxury
 car. Get a motor and a belt. Those things look at the circuit and try to u
nderstand why the made them that way. They knew how to charge a battery.

Site Timeline