OT?: Textured cases/enclosures

Hi,

We've been evaluating some sample enclosures for a handheld device (all roughly the same size/shape just different types of materials). The device has a decent amount of "heft" to it -- light enough to be held comfortably in one hand (but not featherweight like, e.g., a phone). And, there's a significant number of dollars tied up in each one so it's not the sort of thing you want to be dropping often! :>

We opted for a textured finish on the plastic parts as this was "less slippery" and hid many of the superficial scratches that the device encounters during typical use.

But, the texture makes it easy for oils from handling to accumulate "in the cracks". So, the devices start to look pretty shabby *really* quickly!

The texture works against us when it comes to trying to clean up a unit that has accumulated crud -- you can't just "wipe it clean" like you would for a "smoother" finish. We've also learned that the temptation to use solvents to expedite the cleaning quickly mars the finish (depending on the plastic and choice of solvent, this either *just* takes the "sheen" off the plastic *or* actually can start to "dissolve" it!).

We're currently having a sample case milled from a block of aluminum to see how that fares (weight, appearance, etc.). But, this is probably not the way to go in the long run (even if it was cast). Or, we'd need a different approach to the "texture" issue (perhaps significantly modifying the case's shape to make it easier to hold "reliably")...

Does anyone have firsthand experience with the use of texture for these goals? And/or other materials that would be durable, "holdable" and cleanable?

Is there a group/forum better suited to these sorts of questions?

Thx!

Reply to
Don Y
Loading thread data ...

You can't just put it in the dishwasher?

Reply to
Bob Engelhardt

Perhaps a smooth case with a factory supplied rubber "case protector" like those you can buy for iPhones. If it gets scunged up, peel it off, wash it in the sink, dry it and pop it back on.

Reply to
Ralph Barone

Wow! That's an *excellent* idea -- in *so* many ways!

- eases the strain on the hand from holding what would otherwise be a hard, inflexible item

- gives a bit of added protection to the device (think: dropped!)

- can be "smoother" to make cleaning easier

- can be *removed* for cleaning (Bob's "dishwasher" suggestion! :> )

- gives us more flexibility in choice of case materials (since the actual case is now never really exposed)

- inexpensive to replace (though becomes another "supply" that has to be sourced) if it ever gets tattered, gouged, chewed up, etc.

Of course, there will still be solvent issues. But, hopefully "soapy water" will be sufficient to get it clean without resorting to organic solvents.

And, it will constrain the actual final shape of the case so that the "skin" *can* be peeled off without being damaged, etc.

Excellent! Thanks!

Reply to
Don Y

I was posting from my iPod (complete with silicone rubber "skin"), so I can't claim much originality in the suggestion, but I'm glad you liked it.

Reply to
Ralph Barone

When I read your suggestion, I thought more along the lines of the heavy "rubber" (?) sleeves that are present on (around) some of the industrial devices I've purchased. Not as flexible as what you are suggesting but the same idea: if the "skin" of the device is the problem, find a way of changing/replacing/cleaning it *easily*!

Now I will just have to crusade to make it a "low cost" replacement part so folks are encouraged to replace it when it gets "ratty looking" -- instead of clinging to an old, beat-up "skin" out of concern to save some money (since that beat-up skin can reflect poorly on the product itself!)

Reply to
Don Y

Slightly waisted (convex) sides?

Reply to
Pimpom

Offer the replacments in multiple colors so they can 'customize' the units. That way cutomers who have more than one can tell them apart and you can sell even more of the skins. :)

--
You can't have a sense of humor, if you have no sense.
Reply to
Michael A. Terrell

This gets back to my post regarding (paraphrasing) "are we in the *device* business or the *skins* business?".

I'd rather push for making *the* skin (one color/style) available "at cost" and treat the activity of "selling skins" as one that is just a "cost of doing business". Otherwise, it can turn *into* a business -- one that can end up hurting the sale/perception of the device itself. (i.e., pressure to raise the price/profit margin on the skins to pay the salaries of the *extra* folks now taking "skin orders", etc.).

If some 3rd party wants to parasitically benefit from our *not* offering a selection of skins, then so be it. At least that is an *option* that customers can avail themselves of vs. us "extorting" extra dollars from them for a necessary supply/accessory ("Yeah, they make the skins really CRAPPY so you have to keep buying new skins every year! $20 for a silly piece of rubber... Sheesh!")

Reply to
Don Y

Dunno. I'll leave this to the IE/ME types to sort out. I'm sure there are "equations" that determine just what you can and can't do with a given size/shape sleeve made from a particular material trying to slide/stretch over *another* size/shape object made of a *different* material, etc.

(Amusing how "foreign" disciplines can appear to border on black magick! :> )

Reply to
Don Y

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.