lithium fires

Today's NYT describes a nasty fire in an apartment building in Manhattan, started by a bicycle battery. There have been 200 battery-ignited fires in Manhattan so far this year, with six deaths. Unless battery quality improves somehow, buildings will need fireproof vaults for parking bikes and scooters.

I see lots of electric scooters and bikes on the streets of San Francisco lately. Some have gigantic batteries. Those could become hazards as they age. Theft is common so people want to take their rides indoors.

There is also a full-page ad trashing Tesla, claiming that Autopilot won't see a kid in the road.

Reply to
John Larkin
Loading thread data ...

søndag den 6. november 2022 kl. 18.35.33 UTC+1 skrev John Larkin:

do you leave your battery powered tools, laptop or cellphone outside just to be sure?

Reply to
Lasse Langwadt Christensen

I don't have any battery powered tools. Mo has a little whipper thing to make her own foamy coffee, but it uses (a lot of) AA batteries.

I haven't heard of fires from phones or laptops. They use relatively small, low peak power flat batteries so may be less of a fire hazard. Better thermals and maybe different construction from vehicle batteries.

Kilograms (or tons) of densely packed batteries is a whole nother story. Fires seem to be in vehicle batteries.

There aren't many cheap Chinese laptops or phones being sold here; Apple and Dell and Samsung can't take risks with bad batteries. But there are lots of cheap Chinese bikes and scooters.

Reply to
John Larkin

søndag den 6. november 2022 kl. 19.08.51 UTC+1 skrev John Larkin:

then you haven't been listening, Apple, Samsung et.al. have all had cases with battery fires, billion dollar recalls, lawsuit

Reply to
Lasse Langwadt Christensen

I don't, but I frequently wonder if I should.

Jeroen Belleman

Reply to
Jeroen Belleman

We need some kind of flow battery, where the reagents are kept separated until needed. Cheap, efficient, powerful flow batteries are still elusive.

Jeroen Belleman

Reply to
Jeroen Belleman

Don't be obnoxious.

Apple, Samsung et.al. have all had cases with

They don't make the news like the 200 building fires and six deaths in Manhattan this year from bikes and scooters.

How many cell phone fires are there per year in the US?

Reply to
John Larkin

The best battery would use air as one of the reactants.

Reply to
John Larkin

Zinc-air batteries do that. They have been used in hearing aids for many decades. However, they have their own problems. Once the tab that keeps the air out has been peeled off they tend to self-discharge fairly quickly. They are not generally very good at coping with high peak loads either. John

Reply to
John Walliker

søndag den 6. november 2022 kl. 21.19.27 UTC+1 skrev John Larkin:

don't know, but

formatting link
estimated 358,500 home fires occur every year. 50% of these fires start in the kitchen,

7% begin in the bedroom, and 6% are chimney fires, 4% of all residential home fires start in the living room, while 3% start from the laundry room...

..more than 26,000 house fires, caused by faulty wiring...

..On average, seven people die in a fire a day..

so while there is undoubtedly so very bad quality batteries out there it would have to be really bad to "compete" with other sources

Reply to
Lasse Langwadt Christensen

very clever automatic lubricator based on a zinc-air cell

formatting link
battery makes hydrogen pushing out the grease, how fast the grease is pushed out depends on the load on the battery

Reply to
Lasse Langwadt Christensen

Autopilot has trouble with motorcycles too. A number of riders have been run down...

formatting link
formatting link
formatting link
Bad enough dealing with idiot drivers and bad road surfaces, now we have to avoid Teslas!

Sheesh!

I've been riding pretty much year round since around 1972...

John :-#(#

Reply to
John Robertson

Yes, and some liquid as the other.

Jeroen Belleman

Reply to
Jeroen Belleman

The bottom line here is there is a vast variation in the quality of the lithium batteries being produced. I am sure that China can produce high-quality batteries IF they institute the proper rigorous quality control procedures. But many China producers are driven to produce the cheapest, lowest quality batteries possible. You see it in knock-off battery packs for hand tools; the cells inside have NO manufacturer markings whatsoever, and they don't produce the same energy levels. They are just CHEAP so the battery pack is cheaper than the name brand. I just checked a number of reviews today on this issue.

Reply to
Flyguy

Yeah, I believe that test had to do with a car in front of the Tesla suddenly moving out of the lane. So the test dummy child was struck by the Tesla which did not have time to react, just like a human. Of course, the goal is not to be like humans. That's a very low bar. So far, the Teslas have far surpassed humans in safety. But that's not a completely fair comparison, considering the way autopilot is used.

Reply to
Ricky

That's a gasoline engine, no?

Reply to
Ricky

Lol! No one's being obnoxious. He's just pointing out that you clearly don't read much general news. These reports are wide spread when they happen. In other terms, "Big News!"

They make it into a few newspapers and magazines that people read.

formatting link

formatting link
I can't say your question is obnoxious, but it is lazy. You could have typed it into Google rather than your newsreader.

Reply to
Ricky

"The driver of the Model X had his hands on the steering wheel, but was also dozing off behind it."

Sounds like the problem is, as typical, the loose nut behind the wheel.

The Teslas are actually safer than humans statistically speaking. How safe do cars need to be? Maybe you should take a look at the cars that aren't Teslas?

I used to ride a bike, until I was rear ended in DC. He wasn't driving a Tesla.

Reply to
Ricky

183, says google.

Phones top list of fires among electronic devices, says Health ...

formatting link
› news › canada › nova-scotia › hea... Nov 16, 2021 — There were 183 fires reported across the country over the past five years involving phones and their accessories. The second most frequent cause ...

formatting link
Reply to
Carlos E.R.

That's minute compared to 200 building fires in Manhattan alone.

Over five years in Canada?

A 9 volt battery gets pretty hot of you short it. I wonder if that can start a fire.

Reply to
John Larkin

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.