Lattice MachXO2/XO3/XO3D vs ECP5

Can anyone shed some light on why are XO2/3 chips so expenisive compared to ECP5 ?
XO2/3 is supposed to be middle-to-low end of their product lines, but simple
6900 LUT XO3 is significantly more expensive than 12kLUT ECP5.
What gives ?
Reply to
Brane2
Loading thread data ...
to ECP5 ?
ple
ECP5 is a RAM based family much like the Xilinx parts.
The XO, XO2, XO3, XP2 device families are all flash based. I don't know th e details of how their fabrication is different from the RAM based ECP fami lies, but the flash does take up die space if nothing else. I'm sure the f lash capabilities aren't available on the smallest feature size processes.
Lattice also makes the Silicon Blue derived iCE40 families which are non-vo latile as in one time writable ROM based.
--
  Rick C. 

  - Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging 
 Click to see the full signature
Reply to
Rick C
XO families only contain FLASH, they are not flash absed AFAIK.
That is, during the initialisation FLASH still gets internally copied to SRAM.
If the FLASH onboard is the reason for the price, why is 7kLUT XO2 or XO3 so much more expensive than 12kLUT ECP + much bigger SPI FLASH ?
Reply to
Brane2
SRAM.
Yes, but it is very fast, less than a ms in the XP part I use.
so much more expensive than 12kLUT ECP + much bigger SPI FLASH ?
Without the flash the entire chip can be made on a smaller geometry and so, much smaller and cheaper. That is what Xilinx was saying in this forum ma ny years ago as the basis for saying flash FPGA can't compete. Yes, flash FPGA can't compete at the high end. But there is still a market for flash based devices in the low end.
I've always preferred the flash parts because of the simplicity of use and field programming. My real issue with the SRAM based part though is usuall y the packaging. Along with not being low end oriented the other makers li ke the high pin count packages that are harder to use.
--
  Rick C. 

  + Get 1,000 miles of free Supercharging 
 Click to see the full signature
Reply to
Rick C

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.