Design Tradeoffs

Oct 23, 2009 5 Replies

Having spent several rounds of initial specifications with a potential customer, that is less likely to be a viable project as they want to



"Squeeze a gallon into a pint pot"



I could see that the prospect was actually trying to get all THREE sides of the Quality Triangle often referred to as Tradeoff Triangle



Good / \ / \ / \ / \ Fast ---- Cheap



"Pick any two"



I actually think these days it should become the



"Tradeoff Square"



Good ----------- Small | | | | | | Cheap ------------ Fast



"Pick any THREE"



In the ever miniaturising world of keyboards too small for anyone other than a mouse to use.


Paul Carpenter | paul@pcserviceselectronics.co.uk PC Services Timing Diagram Font GNU H8 - compiler & Renesas H8/H8S/H8 Tiny For those web sites you hate

Or you fold "small" into "good".

Sometimes you just have to say 'no' to a potential client, even if you're in dire straits -- if they can't see why they can't have all three sides of the product triangle, they probably can't understand the three sides of the project management triangle either, and will get bent out of shape when they find out that you actually want to get _paid_ for your work, heaven forbid.

www.wescottdesign.com

Often good means performs the perfect job, but it must the size of a postage stamp, cost less than $1..

An often seen example is often expecting to get broadcast audio and video quality out of a camera smaller than a webcam, at full HD frame rates, with half hour full quality storage in MPEG-4 in real time, on postage stamp size PCB and costs $1.

That is what I am doing too often saying 'no', and in one case definitely does not understand the triangle/square.

Paul Carpenter | paul@pcserviceselectronics.co.uk PC Services Timing Diagram Font GNU H8 - compiler & Renesas H8/H8S/H8 Tiny For those web sites you hate

I see projects having 4 factors and a variation in one factor effects the other 3.

QUALITY COST TIME EXPERINCE

If you want a cheaper product then you can reduce the quality / specification.

AND another major problem is the client's have done they business plan homework for the product.

Joe

I sense a bit of cynism about their 'homework' there..

Paul Carpenter | paul@pcserviceselectronics.co.uk PC Services Timing Diagram Font GNU H8 - compiler & Renesas H8/H8S/H8 Tiny For those web sites you hate

Sorry - I meant "haven;t" done their home work.

I had some asked me to build an RF product.... but with out understanding what was required and how much work was involved... more than just the electronics..... tooling for plastics, hardware and mechatonics... Geez..

Joe

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required