ARM GCC bug - No response?

Dec 12, 2020 5 Replies

Anybody ever posted bug reports on GCC as built+distributed by ARM? I posted what I thought was a decently written (and very real) bug report, but I have never received any response at all:

formatting link
Any ideas? Thanks, Best Regards, Dave


You have to wait 10-20 years. By then it's either fixed or disappeared. If it disappeared, resubmit and wait some more.

You didn't provide a sample program that exhibits the problem. And it has been only a few weeks (in holiday season) - perhaps no one from the development team has looked at the report.

George

I have only reported one bug, and you can see how well it has been answered:

Bugs and questions /do/ get answered and fixed on the tracker (I've made a few helpful comments myself to some). But I don't believe the responsible people have anything close to the time and manpower needed to handle the support. They can fix some of the easy stuff. Your issue here - clearly written and important though it is - is far from easy stuff.

It is good to make these bug reports - it stops things getting forgotten, and it makes it much easier for other people to find out about them. However, it is normally best to find a workaround for them rather than waiting for the bug to be fixed.

I'm confused - 3 years on, you did the patch yourself?

In the bug I'm troubled by, there is *no coding required* (unless you count creating a module with 6 empty functions coding). It DOES require messing with the build configuration to use the no-op module to build the ARM library...

I guess I could try do it myself, but I fear days of entanglement with baroque layered build components, plus days trying to set up a suitable build VM...

Thanks, Best Regards, Dave

No. The patch was done in mainline gcc by a gcc developer from ARM, after it was mentioned (by me) in gcc help mailing list discussion on a related topic. I merely reported it back to the gcc arm embedded bug report. You can follow the links from that report, if you are interested. (Perhaps - based on that experience - you might have luck mentioning it on the gcc help mailing list. Along with the gcc developers' mailing list, that's where most of the actual gcc developers hang out - even the ones employed by ARM.)

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required