1. Home
  2. Hobby Electronics Basics
  3. Determining Load in 3 Phase System

Determining Load in 3 Phase System

I'm a system engineer responsible for specifying power quantities for my systems. There are a lot of ways that are accepted in my industry to do this that I know to be incorrect, so I'd like to hear from someone with more specific expertise.

The systems are comprised of a combination of 120V resistive loads, and 208V resistive and inductive loads, although the devices that have inductive loads actually operate at various voltages, their power supplies accept 208VAC. Most of the power available is 208/120VAC

60hz, usually in 400A increments.

What a lot of people do is add up the load P, divide by operating voltage and divide by 3, so if we had 10 500w loads at 120V and 5 at

208V, it would look something like

((5000/110)+(2500/203))/3 = 20A needed.

I can't imagine that's correct. What I have done based on advice and reading is divide the load P by 1.73, a relevant power factor and the supply voltage, so this:

(5000+2500)/(1.73*0.9*203) = 24A needed

But I can imagine that being wrong, also. What is really the way to do this?

Thanks in advance.

Reply to
MammalianFish
Loading thread data ...

I think the correct way to do this is to figure the current for the single phase and three phase loads separately. Also, your example will be an unbalanced load with different current in each phase, because your loads are not integral multiples of 3. But an approximation of average current can be made.

The 10 500W 120 V resistive loads will draw an average of:

5000/(3*120) = 13.9 A per phase.

The 5 500W 208V reactive loads will draw an average of:

2500/(1.73*0.9*208) = 7.72 A per phase.

The total current will approximately 13.9 + 7.72 = 21.6 A.

This is an approximation. A proper calculation would involve the actual impedances of the reactive loads, and a vector sum for the total current. With 0.9 PF, the resistive current would be 6.94 A, and the reactive current 3.38 A. The vector sum would be sqrt( (13.9+6.94)^2 + 3.38^2 ) =

21.11 A.

This still assumes a balanced load, which is not possible with your numbers of resistive and reactive loads.

Paul

Reply to
Paul E. Schoen

Some things to investigate:

The square root of 3 is oft used in 3-phase systems to determine line currents and phase voltages. Power factor is equal to apparent power/power Power is V x I x Cos theta A poor power factor can cause a surcharge on your energy bill and extra current loads on your wires Non-linear loads can cause high neutral currents (sometimes called triplens) An involved subject area ... but doable

Reply to
Charles

Probably a slip of thr fingers, but you wrote, "Power factor is equal to apparent power/power". Actually, power factor is active power/apparent power, where active power id VIcos(theta) and is measured in Watts and apparent power is VI and is measured in Volt-Amps.

Richard

Reply to
Richard Seriani

"Richard Seriani"

** You are both wrong:

Power Factor (PF) = Watts / VA

where -

Watts = the reading you get on a watt meter.

VA = rms volts x rms amps.

rms = reading on a "true rms" volt or amp meter of suitable type.

Cos theta is totally useless, when there is no theta.

...... Phil

Reply to
Phil Allison

Thanks for the correction Richard. Inverted fractions are an on-going problem here :>)

Reply to
Charles

Oh, I forgot to mention that polite corrections are rare here ... I do appreciate your demeanor!

Reply to
Charles

Charles,

I've had nearly 60 years experience making errors and I'm not done, yet. No sense getting upset if someone else makes one.

Richard

Reply to
Richard Seriani

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.