Zenering a big transistor

Jun 26, 2017 57 Replies

ote:

m

.com

diode connected)

imiters. (LND150)

d so far).

mage the junction?

again after

too?

es would do it.

sistors

n

cause

RTDs

ed

s

For production, I measure a temperature* and a voltage drop at CC. And then generate a table of V vs T. I tell them about the delta I/ delta V thing.. I'm guessing most everyone just ignores it, it's only EE geek types that like that kind of thing.

Right, one degree (C or K) is plenty good for most things. Resolution, and changes in temperature are more important.

George H.

*I've got a calibrated diode from lakeshore, which is my temperature 'standard'. I tack that onto the transistor.

te:

com

iode connected)

miters. (LND150)

so far).

age the junction?

gain after

too?

s would do it.

istors

ause

TDs

s
e
d

For kicks, I took 6 irf520 (N-chan fet) stuck 'em to a hunk of copper, near each other. Shorted G to S (after one measured zero volts) and used my DMM to measure the body diode.

0.5893 0.5880 0.5887 0.5890 0.5887 0.5887

That's not too bad. There must be loads on the web about using the fet body diode as a temp sensor.

George H.

e

IUI.

Cryo stuff?

John Larkin Highland Technology, Inc picosecond timing precision measurement jlarkin att highlandtechnology dott com http://www.highlandtechnology.com

.com

te:

hoo.com

r (diode connected)

t limiters. (LND150)

sted so far).

damage the junction?

ge again after

lse too?

iodes would do it.

ransistors

can

because

t. RTDs

s:

ng

ected

ll

ces

he

bias

e

Right, 77- 400 K. The diode connected transistor is going to 'crap out' somewhere below 77 K. Well it will still be a diode but no 'gain' from the collector.

Yes, thanks. I originally saw that in EDN, I think, where it had a better write-up. I used the technique to stabilize a smoke detector design once.

I think it might have been ?Transistor Sensor Needs No Compensatio n,? Jim Williams, EDN, April 25, 1991, but I can't find it just now.

(Update: Okay, I found it. That was the article, but I don't notice any textual differences between that and the file you posted.)

Woodward has a three-current version to reduce ohmic errors.

formatting link

Here are some more of the app notes I scanned through yesterday...

AN137 - Accurate Temperature Sensing with an External P-N Junction

formatting link

AND8494 - Thermal Sensing Methods used in ON Semiconductor Devices

formatting link

AN10349 Digital temperature sensor accuracy explained

formatting link

AN12.14 Remote Thermal Sensing Diode Selection Guide

formatting link

Cheers, James Arthur

Thanks for all those nice links! I collect such things... you never know when such a need will arise. Many of these schemes, difficult in a discrete implementation, are a piece-a-cake in my custom chip world ;-) ...Jim Thompson

| James E.Thompson | mens | | Analog Innovations | et | | Analog/Mixed-Signal ASIC's and Discrete Systems | manus | | STV, Queen Creek, AZ 85142 Skype: skypeanalog | | | Voice:(480)460-2350 Fax: Available upon request | Brass Rat | | E-mail Icon at http://www.analog-innovations.com | 1962 | I'm looking for work... see my website. Thinking outside the box... producing elegant solutions.

77K should be OK. Bipolar devices, transistors and diodes, go to hell below around 20K.

Lakeshore has some magical recipe that makes repeatable temperature measurement diodes at liquid helium temps, but it's not easy. Other people have messed up at this.

John Larkin Highland Technology, Inc picosecond timing precision measurement jlarkin att highlandtechnology dott com http://www.highlandtechnology.com

om

te:

hoo.com

@yahoo.com

nsor (diode connected)

rent limiters. (LND150)

tested so far).

to damage the junction?

ltage again after

g else too?

w diodes would do it.

a transistors

g I can

ool because

g it. RTDs

04's:

going

onnected

t

well

evices

ily

ts,

k the

of bias

t

yone

.

Hmm OK, I have no liquid helium here. So I can't do tests below 77K. It'd be fun to look at commercial diodes at low temps... maybe find one that works. (Is there really a special sauce at Lakeshore?)

George H.

Below 20K, diode voltage drop skyrockets (to, like, volts at a couple K) and things get ohmic. Apparently it's erratic on doping or something, because other people have tried to compete with Lakeshore and every batch was different.

We did the cryo instrumentation for the Jlabs/CEBAF machine, and for the helium liquefaction plant for the Supercollider (which may still be there.)

John Larkin Highland Technology, Inc picosecond timing precision measurement jlarkin att highlandtechnology dott com http://www.highlandtechnology.com

Hmm OK, I have no liquid helium here. So I can't do tests below 77K. It'd be fun to look at commercial diodes at low temps... maybe find one that works. (Is there really a special sauce at Lakeshore?)

George H.

Pull a vacuum on the LN2 and it will go colder than 77K.

Yeah I'd figure there should have been plenty of people trying to make one work, given the price Lakeshore charges. So a project most likely to fail.

Below 20K where are the charge carriers coming from? Very shallow impurities? You could shine a little light on the junction to make carriers.. that's kinda cheating.

George H.

I wanted to use a tuning-fork quartz crystal as a cryo temp sensor, but I couldn't get my customer (who had the facilities to help develop it) interested. They stuck with the Lakeshore diodes, lots of them.

John Larkin Highland Technology, Inc lunatic fringe electronics

Huh, the 32kHz ones? Aren't they made to have a low Temp-co? I guess away from room temp they would change more. They'd have to live in vacuum or the liquid helium might change the frequency. Most people are afraid to try something new... better the devil you know.

George H.

Right ~65K or something like that. I had a friend who did that for an experiment in grad school. He made a big block of solid nitrogen in the dewar.. it took a while to thaw.

George H.

Their TC is parabolic, intended to have the flat spot at human-wrist temperature. At low temps, it's very steep.

I got some samples of a vacuum-sealed 32KHz tuning-fork crystal, but I never had the facilities to test them.

Most people are afraid to try something

They could have at least got some papers to publish!

John Larkin Highland Technology, Inc lunatic fringe electronics

This is almost impossible to read, but I think they take one down to

4.2 K.
formatting link

George h.

Do you use 2 with different tempcos & compare f?

NT

COTS crystals don't have the tempco you want. This is the one I recall:

The high Q of a quartz oscillator implies small self-heating of the sensor. The aging of quartz means it needs recalibration to stay accurate. So, how do you calibrate a 0.0001 K precision thermometer?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required