Re: ping liz@poppyrecords

Oct 07, 2025 Last reply: 9 months ago 4 Replies


I was just reading in comp.os.linux.advocacy about this:


>
formatting link
did you know about that?
>record click removal?

I used that one some years ago - in fact I made some suggestions for improvement in the algorithms.


I don't know whether it will "build" these days, given the changes in the GUI toolkits over the years.


formatting link

That's another one I used years ago... and again, it might or might not be capable of being compiled using current libraries.


The Audacity sound editor has somewhat similar capabilities... automated crackle removal, and semi-manual "point out the glitch and it'll repair the waveform" fix-up for individual pops and ticks. I used it recently to do some cleanup on the transcription of an old LP from my collection, and the results were quite good.

There are a lot of software products on the market but they have two major failings:

1) They don't work in real time, so it is impossible to optimise the mechanical settings whilst listening to the results. If the mechanical settings are wrong, no amount of clever software can put the sound right. 2) Many of them are designed to deal with single clicks (e.g. from a scratched vinyl L.P.) and cannot cope with the hail of crackles from a poor shellac pressing.

The real-time aspect was important last weekend: I was playing-in examples for presentations at the A.G.M. of a national gramophone society. Most of the records only arrived on my table 15 minutes before the presentation started, although I had been told in advance what they would be. The one of the presenters produced a record she had just been given and asked if that could be included too.

In the evening, people brought along records they would like to hear, so I only had a few minutes to look at each disc and work out what settings would suit it. (No normal 78s used the R.I.A.A. recording characteristic, so I had to work out what characteristics to use for each one.) Most were lateral recordings but a few were vertically-modulated. Several were 80 rpm and one was 66 rpm.

There is no way software with batch processing or even noticeable latency could have been used for that job.

[...]

Aye, there's the rub! No time to do that in front of an audience.

You guessed correctly - or they could be connected in parallel as long as the relative polarity was correct in each case. For coping with a mix of records it is much more convenient to have sum and difference op-amps permanently connected, then switch between them. For convenience the switching is incorporated into the equaliser:

formatting link
The variable mid-frequency turnover for mono is achieved by adding a proportion of the integrated signal to the direct signal. This avoids the gain changes that would occur if you attempted to do it with variable feedback around an op-amp.

It's a non-polarised electrolytic capacitor. I always use the pre-war German/Dutch symbol for electrolytics because it is more descriptive than the British Standard symbol. The non-polarised symbol is like two 'Dutch' electrolytic capacitors back-to-back

I use a different symbol for feedthrough capacitors, you can see some in the top row at:

formatting link
The feedthrough symbols with the dashed lines are ferrite beads.

The cartridge pre-amp is a low-noise design that was first used by Bell Labs for telephone line amplifiers in the 1920s, it has a combination of current and voltage feedback to ensure the correct loading without the need for a noise-generating and signal-wasting resistor. The idea was revived by the BBC for their low-noise AMC/5 microphone pre-amplifier in the 1950s. In most implimentations, including this one, it needs both side of the input signal source to float - but I have produced a variant that can work with a source that has one side earthed.

Yes, it is specified by the manufacturers to give a little bit of high frequency correction boost to the sound.

...and 1/30th of the output voltage injected into the bottom end of the cartridge.

630 ohms 720 Millihenries

Needle pickups have their uses - but not for stereo!

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required