Need to compare PIN diode specs

Sep 10, 2005 3 Replies

In the visible, essentially all silicon photodiodes have quantum efficiencies of either 90% (coated) or 60% (uncoated). The exceptions are mainly diodes in coloured packages, e.g. with blue filters for light meters or 800-nm longpass filters for IR remote controls. You're basically comparing areas here.

Cheers,

Phil Hobbs

I have data sheets for two PIN photodiodes. I would like to compare their sensitivities. One of them is specified in mw/cm^2 and the other is in lux.



I have tried to find a way to convert one to another, but it seems that the mw/cm^2 is radiometry terms and lux is a photometry term involving weighting due to the response of the human eye. I'm at a loss.



Here are the relevant data points (I think):



Diode 1 Vishay BPV22NF



80 uA at 1 mW/cm^2 at 950 nm

Diode 2 Sharp PD481PI



5 uA at 100 lux at 960 nm (actually, they say 5 uA at 100 lux using a CIE standard light source (tungsten lamp) but peak sensitivity is at 960 nm)

Any help comparing the relative sensitivities will be greatly appreciated.



Thanks, John


My comment is that it is pretty piss poor that a data sheet for a photo diode does not provide the active area. I bought some of these a while back and noticed this lapse. Someday, I will dissolve the plastic off and measure one.

Hi, Phil -

Both are in plastic IR filter packages. The BPV22NF area is given as 7.5 mm^2 but the PD481PI is not given.

Thanks for your comments.

John

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required