Menlo Micro is making some grand claims for their power and RF relays. They appear to be electrostatic MEMS relays. Lots of people have tried that in the past couple of decades, but the parts haven't been reliable.
MEMS again
Nov 13, 2024
Last reply: 1 year ago
5 Replies
formatting link
On-State Insertion Loss is only stated at 6Ghz. I'd be interested to know what it is closer to the top end. A graph would be better, though.
Ignore that! They did provide one; must have somehow missed it first time.
All the parts can only cold switch. That would seem to be a problem, especially for the power parts. How do you cold switch a circuit breaker?
The two killers of MEMS relays have always been contacts frying and contacts sticking.
Holy crap, I didn't spot that! Big downer.
I'd love a good small-signal MEMS relay. No semiconductor switch can touch its Ron*Coff time constant, and free isolation is cool too. Even a 90 cent telecom relay wins there.
Those Menlo things can probably hot switch low level analog stuff.
I recently used a bunch of Analog Devices switches, ADRF5024, to switch some pulses around. Had to characterize them ourselves for DC operation... ADI was no help. They work fine, for $108 each.
The signals come in at right angles, which dominated the whole PCB layout. Some really tiny SPST switches would be cool... put them anywhere. I like single opamps for the same reason.
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required