Is National getting out of the switched capacitor filter business?

Mar 19, 2010 13 Replies

I am designing a system that really needs a switched capacitor filter or ten. For now I have stuck in the Linear ones that are singles in an SO-8. I have been looking for another maker to see if I have other options and have found to my alarm that it appears that Linear is the only source I can trust.



National: The parts can still be found on the web site with google but there seems to be no way to get to them from the main page. This is usually a sign that the company is about to drop the product line.



Maxim: I've been burned too many times by these guys. They make lots more datasheets than actual parts.



TI: These appear to be only second source versions of the National parts.


Does anyone know of another company that I may have missed? I need to kill off something at, lets say 7KHz on a signal at 1KHz and I have clocks from 1KHz to 128KHz. The actual numbers vary over a 5:1 range so a fixed tuning would have to be a way better filter than one I can tune by changing the clock.


Whosever you use, be careful about aliasing the signal, aliasing any power supply noise, input charge-injection spikes, and output spikes!

And noise. They tend to be noisy.

John

S/C filters have never really caught on, IMHO because they wanted to cram a pricing structure into the market that made these filters unattractive. I am probably one guilty party, having used them on only one design where I had to but not on any others. The sole reason was the high pricing.

Anyhow, personally I trust LTC a lot. The earth would almost have to be hit by a huge meteorite before they discontinue something. Maxim, ahm, well, you've already said all there is to say. Even if they have parts there is never a guarantee that they'll have parts next time the purchasing folks want to order a reel ;-)

Other source, and this might actually save money on some products: Cypress. Many of their PSoC contain several S/C filters, along with other useful analog stuff.

Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ "gmail" domain blocked because of excessive spam. Use another domain or send PM.

John Larkin writes

Aha. So it's not just my lousy layout. I only tried using them once, and was stunned by the (power rail) noise. A simple 100nF decoupler to +5V and -5V just didn't cut the mustard.

However, I generally like and trust Linear Tech stuff. The NatSemi filters didn't seem to have devices with such high specs in their lineup, I got the impression they'd perhaps come up with the idea in the first place but Linear Tech had leapfrogged them and NatSemi had stopped developing them years ago; if NatSemi find they are not selling, they may have stopped emphasising them in their main index?

You've listed all the SC manufacturers I know of.

Nemo

Can't confirm that. My one and only design with lots of S/C filters on board was a medical ultrasound Doppler board. There you need in excess of 80dB in dynamic range, and it delivered. But you've go to have at least partial planes for the supply.

[...]
Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ "gmail" domain blocked because of excessive spam. Use another domain or send PM.

I think I will be changing the whole topology but what I did was: The input of the filter is fed with a fairly simple RC filter from something that should be down by 60db (in theory) by time we get to Nyquist.

The supply is from a linear regulator.

The input side spikes should all end up in the capacitor. The output side fed another simple RC to kill off the steps.

My signal is over 2Vp-p and I only need the noise in the

10Hz either side of the signal to be about 60 dB down.

I'd really like to start trusting Cypress again. I will look at the PSoC chips again. Even though I am changing topology I may find something worth a look.

This may even end up as an ASIC. Currently, the entire hand held device will fit in the back of a pick-up truck.

Where did they disappoint you in the past?

Oh, the Silverado edition of your design :-)

Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ "gmail" domain blocked because of excessive spam. Use another domain or send PM.

[snip]

Bwahahahaha!

Reminds me of the first mockup of an electronic transmission controller at Ford (~1968)... the "breadboard" filled the trunk of the car :-) ...Jim Thompson

-- | James E.Thompson, CTO | mens | | Analog Innovations, Inc. | et | | Analog/Mixed-Signal ASIC's and Discrete Systems | manus | | Phoenix, Arizona 85048 Skype: Contacts Only | | | Voice:(480)460-2350 Fax: Available upon request | Brass Rat | | E-mail Icon at

formatting link
| 1962 | The only thing bipartisan in this country is hypocrisy

[....]

They quite making a part just after I designed it in. I couldn't really get too made at them because it was a CPLD. At this point

100% of the CPLDs I have ever designed in have gone out of production. Two of the companies have gone completely out of the business. A great example is that I designed in the 5V Coolrunners from Philips.

Do they come with a 2nd battery option? I have met the design goal that it run on a single battery. A 100 AH deep cycle isn't quite what marketing had in mind but they are just a bunch of whiners.

Marketing didn't like my proposed name. I wanted to call it the Hindenburg-Titanic Jr and give it the part number

13-444-666.[*] The didn't like that either. What a bunch of whiners. [*] Ask someone from China about the number 4. In one dialect 4 sounds like the word for death.

Programmables are notorious for vanishing. That's why I avoid them as far as possible. Once I almost designed in the Intel series. Man was I glad that I didn't because two years later ... poof.

No idea (probably not as a factory option) but the guys with campers on there usually have an additional deep-cycle.

AFAIK the abbreviation "SMT" sounds like death in Czech, I believe it's "smrt" in their language. They are pretty frugal when it comes to vowels :-)

Regards, Joerg http://www.analogconsultants.com/ "gmail" domain blocked because of excessive spam. Use another domain or send PM.

It is that way in Korean. For that reason, Koreans think of number 4 as a symbol of bad luck.

VLV

I have heard tell that they regard "R" as a vowel.

-- "Electricity is of two kinds, positive and negative. The difference is, I presume, that one comes a little more expensive, but is more durable; the other is a cheaper thing, but the moths get into it." (Stephen Leacock)

On Mar 20, 6:02=A0pm, Joerg wrote: [....]

Things like PICs and 8051s seem to stay around for a while. CPLDs seem to only go away if I design them in. What was the Intel part IIRC a while back I did design something from them into a product too.

I have been thinking that perhaps I should charge companies to not design in their parts.

In my latest design, I have several micros and no CPLDs or even

22V10s. I like the CMOS zero power 22V10s even thought they are kind of slow, they can be used to make about 5 ICs worth of logic per package.

I am using a lot of 74HCxx logic in the design in an effort to keep the power low. One part needs an oven so there are limits on what I can do with circuit design. I really kind of wish that the LT1352's supply current didn't rise so much when you slew them hard. I have had to reduce amplitudes and move to a slower op-amp in one place.

[....]

Seriously: Some folks want to go with some 3 AH Lithiums. Do you have experience with this technology. It worries me that just a little abuse can turn a Lithium into a rocket motor.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required