I have a BTB04-600SL with the anodes giving a reading of 0 Ohms aross them in both directions so it looks as if it's duff and decided to replace it with BTA08-600B. But it still didn't work:-
BTB04-600SL:-
formatting link
4A, 10ma sensitivity on gate, tab connected to A2
BTA08-600B:-
http://www.ortodoxism.ro/datasheets/stmicroelectronics/7472.pdf
8A, 50ma sensitivity on gate, insulated tabSo I think the gate sensitivity is the main problem