So for months my garage setup has been doing that annoying thing where the lights pulse every time my fridge kicks on, then go flat during the quiet parts of songs. The mic on my controller was picking up everything except what I actually wanted it to react to. I tried taping foam around it, moving the whole rig closer to the speakers, none of it really worked.
This weekend I finally swapped to a controller with an actual aux input and ran a cable from my phone at the couch to the controller by the strip. Plugged it in, toggled the input from mic to line in the WLED sound settings, and it just worked. The bass hits land exactly on the drops now. No fridge, no door slams, no dog barking triggering the whole ceiling. The small thing nobody warns you about: your phone needs volume cranked way up for the signal to hit the range WLED expects, otherwise you get a lazy little shimmer instead of the full flash. Took me twenty minutes of fiddling before I figured that out. Also found out the controller passes audio through to my speakers, so I didn't even lose my headphone jack in the deal. shoud have done this a year ago.