Hall effect sensor

I'd like to use a Hall Effect sensor to detect 6 magnets on the outside of a

2.5" rotating cylinder. It rotates at 20 RPM resulting in 120 pulses per minute (I'll calculate speed from this). This will be a damp environment so a ferrous 'target' is not an option.

I have found small inexpensive ring magnets (with the S pole facing out) that I can easily mount on the cylinder. I have NOT found small inexpensive ring magnets that are magnetized diametrically (N and S are on the same face).

There are many many types of Hall Effect sensors. Most need alternating N and S fields: either with 2 opposite poled magnets, or with a single N/S ring magnet. Is there a type that can detect the coming and going of just a S field (the field will never be totally absent)?

I found a Gear Tooth Sensor type that senses a ferrous target. Can I just use the S facing ring magnet instead of the ferrous target?

TIA

Reply to
thomas
Loading thread data ...

Why worry about a ferrous target in the damp - it doesn't worry many car & motorcycle makers, you could also apply protective lacquer. In any case ferrous alloys used for magnetic applications tend to form a thin film of rust and then stop corroding unless fully exposed to weather, note also that hall sensors are favoured for their immunity to environments that would foul up opto sensors.

Reply to
ian field

I think the gear tooth sensor will do just fine. You can also use any small tranformer,from which you can remove the iron on one side of the coil. Unless of course your speed can go to zero, in which case you need the hall type tooth sensor. You could also try a reed relay, they have a long lifetime as long as they only have to switch a small current.

Reply to
Sjouke Burry

a
r

t so

sive

N

Here's a link that helps explain the types of hall sensors:

formatting link

e

That's called a unipolar sensor; sensitive only to one magnetic polarity, typically south. Example: Honeywell's SR13C-A1. I used that sensor to convert a motorcycle distributor from points to solid state. I installed quarter inch diameter neo magnets in a fixed aluminum disc above the base plate, one hall sensor on the base plate directly below each magnet, and had a steel shutter disc rotating between the magnets and the sensors, to break the magnetic field. Some ancillary circuitry to drive the ignition coil. It worked the first time I turned over the engine.

st

Well, I've never used that kind of sensor, so I can't say it would work. But I would encourage you not to give up on the hall sensors. I had an easy time with them. If you use a unipolar sensor and get it installed the right distance from the magnets you shouldn't have any problem. This is as much a mechanical job as an electronic one.

Reply to
gearhead

As others have mentioned, a gear tooth sensor should be just fine. The standard "reluctance" sensor is just a magnet plus a coil of wire around a ferrous core. The coil senses changes in the magnetic field caused by the gear teeth concentrating the flux momentarily as they pass by.

But if you really want to mount rotating magnets, then all you need for a sensor is a coil of wire around a core. The whole thing can be potted in plastic if you are worried about moisture.

If you have a junkyard nearby, you might cannibalize an old automotive distributor from the days before electronic timing. (But which still used electronic ignition.)

The GM design used an 8-tooth "gear" that rotated inside a ring with 8 teeth pointing inward so that they came very close to the "gear" teeth. That gave much higher output than the conventional single geartooth sensor (used by Ford and others).

Best regards,

Bob Masta DAQARTA v3.50 Data AcQuisition And Real-Time Analysis

formatting link
Scope, Spectrum, Spectrogram, FREE Signal Generator Science with your sound card!

Reply to
Bob Masta

Check out

formatting link
where you will find many unipolar Hall Effect sensors. A word or two of advice from my own experience. When I used them I found they worked OK, but the range was poor, even when using an expensive neodymium magnet [See note 1]. Say 3mm. We got another mm or so by putting a ferrite bead behind the magnet. Mind you these were small magnets - about 3mm diameter, 3mm long. You gotta worry about the magnetic field strength dropping with time (years) and temperature (I forget if the magnets get weaker as temperature goes up or down, the manufacturer will tell you). So, just be careful about separation between sensor and magnet. If you have a rotating thingy, and the environment is rugged, you may need to mount the sensor & magnet rather far apart to allow for vibration, knocks, misalignment etc (the same would be true of an opto sensor).

If cost is no object I know of another technology being developed at a start up company near me, they're looking for apps. This one sounds suitable but would need to be a mass production or high value one to justify them developing a custom solution for you.

I wouldn't go for a reed switch as they're electromechanical and I just don't trust such things' failure rates when cycled a zillion times. Also I have seen some which were orientation sensitive. They do have the advantage of not caring what polarity they're facing, though.

Something to consider: why does the rpm sensor need to be mounted near the gear teeth?

Note 1 - neodymium magnets ===================== Neodymium alloys make the best magnets because (a) they're strong (b) they retain their strength even without a keeper forever. Other magnet types' strength decays significantly within a year or two.

Marvellous! So why are these magnets so expensive? Because it's a rare element. There used to only be 2 mines in the world, but the US one closed down for environmental reasons. The remaining one is in China (actually they get the neodymium by processing the waste tailings from a mine which is mainly extracting some other mineral). However a year or two ago that mine had a fire and temporarily closed down, so the price of neodymium magnets shot up. I imagine it's back down again by now.

Just thought that was interesting...

--
Nemo
Reply to
Nemo

nem', Thanks for all the very relevant info! I did get in a sample from Allegro and with a 8mm neo magnet am getting 15mm range. I'll have to play around with magnet size and sensitivities but I think it will work. t

Reply to
thomas

Glad it was of help! I'm a bit of a newbie on this newsgroup and wanted to contribute something. Good luck.

--
Nemo
Reply to
Nemo

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.