LLC with an explicit discrete Lm

Nov 24, 2019 15 Replies

I need a number (~20) of fixed voltages in the range of 4-20V. Isolated and non-isolated, for SIC MOSFET gate drivers, 20V for a small D class audio amplifier, 3.3V and 5V for logic and 10V for some auxiliary circuits. The input voltage is in the range of 10.8-15V, maybe 40W in total.



Due to the number of output rails the complexity of the secondary sides does matter. This basically kills all the PWM forward-derived topologies, as they need output inductors. A flyback might be an option, but I am considering a different aapproch: a stiff LLC "pump" propelling several way-too-good toroidal transformers (primary Lm in the millihenry range), connected in parallel. This will allow me to optimize their properties to match the requirements of a given rail and keep the number of windings within the sane range. Lower inter-winding capacitace of unrelated secondaries would be a benefit too. I'll try to make the effective primary inductance match the LLC design requirements, but if it is too high, I plan to compensate with a parallel choke. Something along the lines of the ideal transformer model of an LLC converter, but this time the equivalent circuit is taken literally.



Has anybody seen anything like that before? Does it make sense?



Best regards, Piotr


A multi-output forward doesn't need inductors and has decent cross-regulation, but you can't PWM regulate. How about a buck switcher ahead of the forward?

Or no regulation ahead but low-drop linear or switching regs after, as needed. I've done that a few times.

Power supply design is often a giant puzzle.

John Larkin Highland Technology, Inc lunatic fringe electronics

This reminds me the buck-pre-regulated push-pull and indeed is a viable option. An unregulated Baxandall driving the trafos through a magnetic amplifier is another.

Too complex overall. Curently I have been considering the TV-like approach: make the transmitting side overly complex for the beneft of simplified receivers. Can have a big net gain, given the number of secondaries.

Surprisingly, it is the auxiliary PSU that drives me nuts. The main power train turned out to be pretty straightforward, even if pretty advanced: a totem-pole PFC powering a high-voltage LLC converter.

Best regards, Piotr

Small switchers, like TPS54302, with a cheap stock inductor, are easy. So it can make sense to keep the power parts, especially the transformer, simple and regulate on the secondary. Really small stuff can use linear regs.

If your main converter has to make a lot of AC anyway, maybe you can couple that into some small transformers to get the low power stuff.

John Larkin Highland Technology, Inc lunatic fringe electronics

On a sunny day (Sun, 24 Nov 2019 18:22:03 +0100) it happened Piotr Wyderski wrote in :

For the boost converter I have this:

formatting link
cannot make it for 2$28 free shipping, works very well here. For the lower voltages up to 5A a switcher with LM2596 only takes a few cm^2, cost very little, even for 20 pieces., using those in several projects. For isolated gate drive probably with not much current wind some E I core using good insulated wire .. use a flat cable for multi-turns, 1V/turn.

?

I like this part, but it solves only the easier part of the problem.

The isolated auxiliaries need to be energized even when there is no AC power, using battery backup. So it is simpler to power the smaller converter from the secondary end of the main LLC.

Best regards, Piotr

Consider planar -- the resonant thing I showed earlier has pretty good cross regulation. There's about 10nH between the secondaries.

Toroids are fine too, just a pain to wind. If you're farming them out then do it however you like. ;D

To get comparable leakage, you will need short winding lengths, and preferably use twisted pairs or even quads for each winding to keep the impedance low. Also, TLT techniques don't mind what the core is, it just needs to up the magnetizing impedance.

Also, don't mind adding LDOs to clean up [cross]regulation, it's just one more part, not a huge burden.

Also also, you can save some diodes if you use CT windings, which would be a pain for a hand wound transformer, but is almost free in planar. Just a PITA to design them...

Tim

-- Seven Transistor Labs, LLC Electrical Engineering Consultation and Design Website:

formatting link

Hi Tim

Can you post a link to the planar thingie?

Cheers

Klaus

formatting link
formatting link
(mind, proto testing changes not included)

Tim

Seven Transistor Labs, LLC Electrical Engineering Consultation and Design Website: https://www.seventransistorlabs.com/

That's really impressive, but I don't see how a planar could host that many windings.

Not a problem, there is a company that could wind them in quantity. Now it is for a proto, so the winding complexity is not a big issue.

Times the number of secondaries, 15 parts then (not all voltages need to be regulated).

The plan for this week: grab an LM5041, extract the full glory of it in the cascaded configuration and see if it suits my needs. Unfortunately, the built-in drivers are not particularly strong, so MOSFET selection will be a PITA. It looks promising and I can have SR drive for free (well, at the cost of even more windings...).

Best regards, Piotr

Apparently it does make sense, but I wasn't the first who invented exactly this combo:

formatting link

LOL! :-)

Best regards, Piotr

out

speaking of synchronous rectification, this is a neat idea,

formatting link
l

d

em out

o

tml

Nice, could not find a price.

English datasheet:

formatting link

ood

t

them out

st

to

in

y,

.html

0.2 USD:

formatting link
l

On a sunny day (Wed, 27 Nov 2019 15:09:36 -0800 (PST)) it happened Klaus Kragelund wrote in :

Interesting, always a RC network needed across it?

This is a typical RC snubber, often found in synchronously rectified flybacks in order to make the life of the MOSFET bearable.

Best regards, Pior

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required