I am considering to buy one of the Spectran spectrum analyzers in this range:
formatting link
I am aware of the many uses up to 2.5GHz, but what type of signal sources would I not be able to measure by not going for a 4, 6 or 8 GHz model?
I refer to the spectrum coverage here, not sensitivity which also seems to increase with each 100 or so euros.
BTW has anyone seen any product that is better value than these for the price?
Colin Style
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
N
Nico Coesel
Why do you want to buy a spectrum analyzer? What do you want to measure with it? BTW also look at the start frequency of the spectrum analyzer.
Failure does not prove something is impossible, failure simply
indicates you are not using the right tools...
nico@nctdevpuntnl (punt=.)
--------------------------------------------------------------
G
Glenn
Hi Colin
How about a vector network analyzer (VNA)?:
Network analyzer (electrical):
formatting link
Quote: "...An SNA is functionally identical to a spectrum analyzer in combination with a tracking generator..."
Links:
formatting link
(PS: I have absolutely no experience with these products)
TAPR Vector Network Analyzer:
formatting link
electronicspecifier.com: PC-based 3MHz to 3GHz Vector Network Analysers:
formatting link
M
mpm
.
My advice: Before you buy ANY spectrum analyzer, try to read the following two books:
Modern Spectrum Analyzer Theory and Applications Modern Spectrum Analyzer Measurements
While pricey, you can still get them on Amazon.
Both are authored by Morris Engelson, and IEEE Fellow and past president (or past vice-president?) of engineering at Tektronics, a leading manufacturer of high-performance spectrum analyzers. He goes to great lengths in the Theory & Applications book on exactly what SA specifications mean, what they DO NOT, and how to compare two analyzers that have differing specifications under real-world conditions. Morris used to give great seminars on the specification, selection and use of spectrum analyzers on real-world problems, but he may have now retired from such things...? His books, used in those seminars, are pure gold - in my opinion. . Here's a sample of what I'm talking about from his website:
formatting link
-mpm
To answer your question, you can review Part-2, FCC Rules, to review US frequency allocations, etc... TV point-to-point microwave is often in the 7 GHz band, for example. That said, you should only buy what you really need - unless you are loaded with cash. These days, frequency range is much less important that a lot of the signal processing apps that are glommed onto the machine. It depends on what you do (or intend to do) with the instrument. You may find an analyzer dedicated to the task at hand is much more useful than a general purpose model that covers a great deal of spectrum.
G
Glenn
Hi Colin
Can you plainly tell what you intend to measure? Fun? Repair? Education? (Why?)
G
Glenn
Hi Colin
There is also waterfall SA/receivers - real-time SA:
formatting link
You simply drag the yellow filter over the frequency interval you want to hear...that is how easy a receiver is today ;-)
formatting link
Press the button 160m, 80m, 40m...at your choice - if no other is using the receiver?
WebSDR at K7UEB the Walla Walla University Club Station:
formatting link
formatting link
Not on-line pt: WebSDR on nine bands:
formatting link
A Brief Discussion of Some Software DSP Solutions I've tried:
formatting link
Quote: "... DSP is an acronym for "Digital Signal Processing". Anytime an analog signal is converted to digital form and processed in some way, that is DSP. The use of DSP techniques in amateur radio is exploding, both in terms of its use in commercial transceivers and receivers, and in terms of homebrew hardware and software construction projects available to and undertaken by hams .... I have found that Linrad does an absolutely superb job of allowing me to hear the desired weak signal hidden in the midst of the all the noise and clutter present at my QTH. It does this better than any other receiving system I have ever tried. .... By clicking with the mouse cursor at any point on the waterfall .... IT IS POINT AND CLICK RECEIVING!!! .... If you want a different filter bandwidth or shape factor, you just take the mouse over to the baseband display, and drag the filter curve wider or narrower, and the filter adjusts graphically. THIS REALLY WORKS!! ...."
On-line VLF receiver (selected dynamic spectra):
formatting link
-
formatting link
formatting link
formatting link
Online Web Receivers:
formatting link
G
Glenn
On 7 Maj, 16:40, Glenn wrote: ...
...
Wrong ;-)
Actually many users can simultaneously listen and change receiving frequencies.
You can even see what others are listening to.
/Glenn
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.