The recoil of a hose when the tap is suddenly opened

Dec 12, 2006 23 Replies

without gripping the bottom of the bag the fish can impart no net force on the side of the bag. neither can he create torque.

About all that can be managed are impulses by colliding with the side of the bag, or causing waves.

Bye. Jasen

most fish are neutrally boyant, hence the approximate density of water.

other non-swimming sea creatures, (snails, crusataceans etc) are denser.

Bye. Jasen

jasen wrote in news:emeo29$53b$ snipped-for-privacy@jasen.is-a-geek.org:

Thanks, captain obvious.

The answer lies in the Conservation of Momentum.

In the frame of reference of the table upon which the bag rests, and assuming the fish and water are initially at rest, then the initial momentum of the bag and its contents is zero. Once the fish starts moving, its forward momentum is be cancelled by the movement of the bag and/or water so that the total momentum remains at zero. If the fish accellerates sufficiently, the resulting backward force might be enough to overcome the static friction with the table, cause the bag to roll backward a little. Or, if the fish accelerates slowly and then collides with the wall, the bag might jump forward as depicted in the movie. Momentum is conserved in each case but energy is transferred to the bag of water. A child sitting in a cardboard box and lurching it forward by aggressive rocking employs a similar technique.

-- Joe Legris

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required