measuring impedance

Dec 31, 2011 71 Replies

"captoro" "Phil Allison" "captoro"

** You must answer this or I am out of here.

I measured it with my genrad 1657 and another cheap brand reader and they gave me the same reading.

** Are you shorting the other winding- cos that figure is more like the leakage inductance.

Do the simple math.

0.35H at 60 Hz is 131ohms = 1 amp at 120 VAC.

I smell a very bad fish ...........

.... Phil

e

I have three of these transformer at 100VA, my third one measures

361mH, they are all in the same range, I have nothing connected to the transformer when I take my measurements.

Ken

?

formatting link

And how are we determining that we are not getting any resonance?

If I were you, for a simple basic line test. I'd have nothing connected the secondary and place a non inductive series R device in series with the primary to connected to the 120 Volt source.

Most transformers of that size should have enough current in the primary to allow for lets say a 50 watt incandescent lamp to be used as a resonance test.

Also beware that some transformers have a shunt in the core design to force some saturation, this is to reduce the effects of resonance with capacitor loads. Commonly found in microwave ovens and such. Maybe you're dealing with this?

Jamie

Get an HP4194. Little LCR meters aren't meant for serious work.

that night be a little expensive for me right now. I am using a variable AC input. with a lamp in the primary, its not lighting up but my input is 10vAC and the output is 30Vac, so I guess I am getting some resonance now. I will play around with the parts. thanks for the help, anymore feedback will be appreciated. and happy new year to all.

ken

"captoro"

I have three of these transformer at 100VA, my third one measures

361mH, they are all in the same range, I have nothing connected to the transformer when I take my measurements.

** What is the resistance of each winding ?

... Phil

Is that the inductance of the primary or secondary?

Disregard. I just found earlier where you said it was 120/120.

"John S"

Quote from OP:

-------------------------------------------------------------

I am using a 120v/120v 100VA transformer, primary in 120v, the secondary I want to make it resonate at 60hz, the inductance reading is 0.352H, so from calculation I am suppose to use a 20uF cap. So I got the motor run caps, and a few t 1uF to make adjustments, I am not getting any resonance..

---------------------------------------------------------------

** He's nuts.

... Phil

Anyone attempting to resonate the primary of a microwave oven tranny is a clear candidate for a Darwin award.

"Bruce Varley"

** The OP is attempting to resonate a 120V to 120V AC supply transformer * at 60 Hz * by connecting a 20uF film cap to the secondary.

He is failing and will continue to fail.

.... Phil

I measured a 50VA transformer I have here with an LCR meter at 1kHz and it was 442mH. I then measured the unloaded line current to be 72mA at

124VAC, 60Hz. That's about 4.5H for the primary inductance.

My conclusion is that I cannot rely on my LCR meter to give the correct inductance for a 60Hz transformer. My LCR meter still read only 538mH at

100Hz. I think the meter does not supply enough force to get things moving properly.

If he really wants to know the primary inductance, he should measure the current when the transformer is plugged into the line and make the calculation. That won't necessarily resolve is resonating problem, as you say.

John S

the

What frequency is the measurement being made at?

?-)

** As I posted earlier, his L figure is out by a factor of 10 to 100.

If it were a toroidal tranny, L would be about 50H.

** AC supply transformers have L values that are high and non linear.

** The primary and secondary windings are well coupled at 60Hz - that is the issue to OP is studiously ignoring .

.... Phil

er

it

AC,

t

ing

e

ou

at is

yes phil, my reading in the last post were erronated (.. not good) I understand after the load , the inductance changes. I then decided to use commercial inductor like a 330uH from delavan and a 3.3uF cap. still not getting any resonance at any frequency . I was using for this test a frequency generator.

K

--- Well, something's definitely wrong then.

From: 1 f = -------------- 2pi sqrt(LC)

1 = ---------------------------- ~ 4825Hz 6.28 * sqrt(3.3nH * 3.3nF)

If you're using a signal generator, you should be able to see resonance a couple of different ways: (View using a fixed-pitch font)

First, since the reactances of the coil and the cap are low:

Xl = 2pi f L = 6.28 * 4825Hz * 330µH = 10 ohms

If the signal generator approximates a voltage source with a very low output impedance, this will work:

. +------+ . | | . | [330µH] . | | .[GEN] +--------+ . | | | . | [3.3µF] [DETECTOR] . | | | . +------+--------+

That is, the voltage peak at resonance should be discernible at Vout, and the higher the impedance of the detector (scope, DVM, whatever) the higher the peak.

However, if the signal generator has an appreciable output impedance this will work better:

. +------+--------+ . | | | . [Rg] [330µH] | . | | [DETECTOR] .[GEN] [3.3µF] | . | | | . +------+--------+

What you'll see at resonance won't be a peak, it'll be a dip, and the sharpness of the dip will be determined largely by the generator's output resistance, the DC resistance of the coil, and the ESR of the capacitor.

Here's the LTspice circuit list so you can play around with the circuit:

Version 4 SHEET 1 880 680 WIRE 192 48 48 48 WIRE 192 80 192 48 WIRE 48 96 48 48 WIRE 48 208 48 176 WIRE 192 224 192 160 WIRE 48 336 48 288 WIRE 192 336 192 288 WIRE 192 336 48 336 WIRE 48 384 48 336 FLAG 48 384 0 SYMBOL cap 176 224 R0 SYMATTR InstName C1 SYMATTR Value 3.3µ SYMBOL ind 176 64 R0 SYMATTR InstName L1 SYMATTR Value 330µ SYMBOL voltage 48 192 R0 WINDOW 123 24 124 Left 2 WINDOW 39 0 0 Left 2 SYMATTR InstName V1 SYMATTR Value "" SYMATTR Value2 AC 1 SYMBOL res 32 80 R0 SYMATTR InstName R1 SYMATTR Value .1 TEXT 56 360 Left 2 !.ac oct 1024 1000 10000

If you don't have LTspice you can get it, free, at:

formatting link

-- JF

On Mon, 02 Jan 2012 05:56:24 -0600, John Fields wrote: . . .

Oops... It doesn't matter what the reactances of the L and C are, since at resonance they cancel.

Here is the circuit:

formatting link

I tried 10 different capacitor values, different inductors including some transformers. I am not getting any resonance. I put the oscilloscope probe across the inductor and across both inductor and cap. There is something else that is not told. I do the exact circuit that is shown here in this java simulation:

formatting link

if this continues I am going to start that resonance is a myth, and everyone is conspiring against me LOL Ken

Here is the circuit:

formatting link

I tried 10 different capacitor values, different inductors including some transformers. I am not getting any resonance. I put the oscilloscope probe across the inductor and across both inductor and cap. There is something else that is not told. I do the exact circuit that is shown here in this java simulation:

formatting link

if this continues I am going to start that resonance is a myth, and everyone is conspiring against me LOL Ken

uit.jpg

HI John,

I installed LT spice, but just tell me where to paste the Circuit list. I browsed the menus . I see Spice Netlist in the view menu, but I cannot edit it.

k

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required