One those 100Ks might have been open. When you unsoldered them you "fixed" them. This will not be permanent.
That was a problem sometimes, I learned to just use circuit values. Unless it is tube stuff you you cannot even check them in circuit, and you heat th e leads to take them out of circuit and many of the "heal up" all the sudde n, which can lead you down the garden path.
Been there done that. I would change them, what are we taking here ten cent s ? That vs customer satisfaction is easy to figure out. Any circuit with e ven those slightly ambiguous results, change the high value resistors.