I generally seek out the actual spec sheet on what I need to replace. I hav e seen NTE, ECG and SK books to be wrong.
I consider many things when choosing a replacement. If it is a switcher the n I look at the turnoff time mainly if it runs into an inductive load. If i t is analog I look at a few other things.
It seems like some of these "resources" do noyt consider all the parameters . They for example had a replacement for an RCA 164589 diode which is a hig h speed rectifier. I told the boss "This is not going to work", he ordered me to put it in anyway and it lasted less than a minute. That was straight out of the ECG book, and NTE is a cheap knockoff on ECG. It is Nutone, ECG was Sylvania, SK is/was RCA.
The only way I'll take the word of a cross reference guide is if I got the JEDEC or JANTX numbers for the parts and can see the whole datasheet. those engineers don't waste money on a transistor when they could have used the old dime a dozen 2N3055. They get paid to save money, not to spend it.
So when you see a transistor that only has 50 volts across it and passes 2 amps, that doesn't mean that any transistor will work if it meets those spe cs.
For example, in a Zenith TV many years ago it had a funny looking picture. I found that in the IF module someone had replaced a video amp transistor w ith an RF power transistor. "WOW, this one'll do 50 MHZ, it must work !". Y eah, it worked but the picture looked like a cartoon because it was not lin ear in its gain. It was designed for use in a class C RF power output or dr iver circuit, not a linear amp.
Anyway, I trust nobody when it comes to replacements. If that thing breaks again it comes back on ME, and since the world is not really all that toler ant of my mistakes, I will do unto others.
Here's a project to test out this cross reference : change the outputs and drivers in a Marantz 1152DC. There's a test because you have to consider th e Vbe before a transistor turns on and the Vcesat of the predrivers. The bi as is not adjustable.
Who do you want picking your replacements then ?
At any time you can make a post here about a replacement and I will probabl y respond. Take advantage of that before something or someone kills me.