Anyone got time to help "Manny"?
If you have then perhaps you could also answer his physics questions as well over on sci.physics :-)
Modelling Photoelectric Effect Without Photons All 2 messages in topic - view as tree Manny Jul 1, 10:52 pm show options
Newsgroups: sci.physics From: "Manny" - Find messages by this author Date: 1 Jul 2005 19:52:01 -0700 Local: Fri,Jul 1 2005 10:52 pm Subject: Modelling Photoelectric Effect Without Photons Reply | Reply to Author | Forward | Print | Individual Message | Show original | Report Abuse
In 1905. There is still no good model of the atoms. Why can't one say that as the frequency of the electromagnetic field increases, the electron orbital can no longer take the energy and so gets ejected from the atom. Why does it have to be a photon particle hitting the electron. What if the electron orbital can only accept certain energies in terms of the frequencies and when it exceed it, the electron orbital gets destructed resulting in the electron leaving the atom?
Has anyone got an alternative atomic model whereby photoelectric effect can occur without using the concept of photon particles? For those who hate photons (like Dr. Richard Perry). You must come up with how the atomic can eject the electron by mere electromagnetic wave energy. This also goes for the compton scattering.
Manny