The dumbest design flaw I've seen in a while.

Bought this piece of junk at a garage sale.

formatting link

Sounds OK enough for what it is. Not using it with an iphone, I just wanted something better sounding than my laptops built in speakers on the front porch for the summer.

The problem: If the thing doesn't detect any sound for about 10 seconds, it goes into power management mode and cuts out the amp. If you're listening to music that has quiet sections you'll get chunks of audio cut out of the music while the amp turns back on!

Good grief, the idiot engineer who designed this! I hope he got his pink slip.

Maybe this winter I'll open it up and see if there's a way to disable this "feature".

Reply to
JW
Loading thread data ...

You haven't listened to music radio stations recently. Most "popular" music is designed and engineered to have a constant loudness.

Reply to
Tom Gardner

a bigger cap should make it a minute

NT

Reply to
tabbypurr

Probably a timing given by a micro processor. Then the only way to defeat it is to inject a periodical signal that is above the audio range but still recognizeable by the detector. Got to watch out that it doesn't annoy animals though as they can often hear much higher frequencies than we do.

--
Regards, Joerg 

http://www.analogconsultants.com/
Reply to
Joerg

This was an issue many years ago - 1973[1] or thereabouts - at BBC radio before 24 hour broadcasting. The transmitters were fitted with a circuit which would switch them off if there was more than a minute[1] of silence.

BBC Radio 3 was and is a classical music station[2]. A minute[1] of 'aesthetic pause' wasn't uncommon.

[1] Whatever. Something like that. Too long ago. [2] Probably the best in the world.

Cheers

--
Syd
Reply to
Syd Rumpo

I found a bookshelf amp with speakers that a neighbor was giving away for free. The built-in tape player makes an annoying noise on startup but it makes an amazing amp for the computer.

Maybe listen to music without quiet spots? :)

formatting link

Michael

Reply to
mrdarrett

A simple picaxe monitoring the input and putting out a low level burst of noise at 9 seconds would work - easy to knock up too. Could also be done with some 555's (missing pulse detector) plus glue

Reply to
David Eather

I sorta expect that this isn't a problem for the product's intended demographic: the very large number of young folks who listen to modern pop music, which simply doesn't *have* any 10-second quiet periods in it. It's all been loudencompressified to death, has a total dynamic range of maybe 3 dB on a really good day, and is either THERE or ( )

Thanks for the warning, though - I won't buy such a monstrosity myself. I have this atavistic preference for dynamic contrasts and subtlety in the music I play...

Reply to
Dave Platt

I'd like to find a decent remote bluetooth speaker that doesn't use a battery and doesn't cost an arm and a leg. I had some old Sony speakers that I got off Freecycle and got an $18 bluetooth module for music in a car. I lucked out and the internal PSU put out about 30 volts which was in the range for the module. I embedded it and it worked great. I had the speaker close by so I could tweak the volume knob (my preference over on PC controls) but didn't need another wire plugged into my laptop which moves around.

I worked pretty well for about a year until it stopped pairing with my PC. I'm not certain if it is a hardware problem or a software problem on the PC. I need to see if my phone can see it.

--

Rick C
Reply to
rickman

The producer was suppoosed to 'book out' any extended silences so that the transmitter engineers were warned in advance, the automatic circuit could the be over-ridden.

The transmitters didn't switch off immediately, they switched to an incoming feed via an alternative route or an off-air receiver tuned to another station in the chain.

--
~ Adrian Tuddenham ~ 
(Remove the ".invalid"s and add ".co.uk" to reply) 
www.poppyrecords.co.uk
Reply to
Adrian Tuddenham

Decided winter is still too far away to live with this idiotic flaw.

formatting link
've-seen-in-a-while/msg1023011/#msg1023011 Fixed.

Reply to
JW

But that's too pedestrian and not sporty enough :-)

A real manly solution would be a transistor stage in the shape of a regenerative receiver, except that the stage is tuned to some really high audio frequency instead of RF and is squegging into brief oscillation bursts.

--
Regards, Joerg 

http://www.analogconsultants.com/
Reply to
Joerg

Yes. That is refered to as CCAA. Continuous Cacaphonous Auditory Assault. Responsible for much of the brain numbness plagueing the youth today.

Reply to
doh

Yep - in my older age I've stopped being sporty - ever seen a 100kg man run without a shirt (don't try to visualize - it's not good). My concern with near/low ultrasonics were possible filters, a/d acquisition times and driving the nearest dog/teenager mad. Hum..., put that way.... there could be advantages.

Reply to
David Eather

Don't stop. Becoming sedentary is a fast and at some point irreversible path into a nursing home. Now that I am gradually approaching retirement age I have upped my game when it comes to mileage on the mountain bike and road bike. Once I can ratchet down to 3days/week or less I'll start doing 80-100 milers, all day rides.

I regularly see such a guy on bike trips east. It is not a pretty sight.

Probably only a tiny amplitude is needed here and the speaker will have very poor efficiency so not much gets through the chain. Also, one might be able to simply use a continuously running oscillator which has the least chance of disturbance.

--
Regards, Joerg 

http://www.analogconsultants.com/
Reply to
Joerg

That's not bad. Did you find out how the micro was detecting sound?

Reply to
bloggs.fredbloggs.fred

VCR clocks.

Reply to
krw

Not becoming sedentary is not a choice I can make. I do what I can but it is a long way from bench pressing more than my body weight and squatting almost double - plus fun with karate. I loved it. But I mustn't dwell or the 'black dog' will come and bite me.

Now that I am gradually approaching retirement

It's strangely hypnotic. Yes, it's like a lava lamp. Mulder and Scully (Simpsons quote)

Just musing - a random noise source (pink or brown) might work well. If the environment is loud enough it might even pass totally unnoticed.

Reply to
David Eather

A handheld digital meter with 'power saving' issues an audible warning beep when it has decided to save power due to inactivity, although it is serving it's function with a non-zero or non/overange display. Nothing you do subsequently will prevent the shut-off, except recycling the power before it happens.

RL

Reply to
legg

Sure, if some other health issue comes in that can place a major damper on activity.

It's plain ugly.

It depends on how they structured the detector. Most likely it is doing its job in the digital domain. It should be happy with a constant or almost constant noise because many people listen to the soothing sounds of ocean waves. Gentle ones, not the daredevil surfboarder type of wave.

--
Regards, Joerg 

http://www.analogconsultants.com/
Reply to
Joerg

ElectronDepot website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.